|
The Cliché Paradox
Alexandre Kimenyi
Clichés have both the yin and yang features. They can be food but also
toxin for the mind. Since they already contain preconceived ideas, they can
affect people's way of thinking, leading them to cliché thinking instead
of critical thinking thus treating myths for realities and stereotypes for prototypes.
Despite this, however, clichés play a very important role in facilitating
communication, in preserving collective memory and are very crucial in the cognitive
process.
The study of clichés clearly shows not only the overabundance of "prepackaged
ideas" but also that the lexicon and not the syntactic structure occupies
a more central position in the mental landscape. Over the last four decades,
syntax has received more attention in theoretical linguistics than other branches
of linguistics such as phonology, morphology and semantics because it was thought
to offer more insight into the mental cognitive structure. In reality, the lexicon
seems to be more prominent as evidenced by the use of pidgins in which people
are able to communicate and understand each other even if sentence structures
are rudimentary or ungrammatical. The existence of clichés thus argues
very strongly for the lexicalist hypothesis over the transformationalist hypothesis.
Since syntactic rules are very minimal, clearly the heavy burden in cognition
is on the lexicon. There are many complex structures which don't belong to syntax
but are already part and parcel of the lexicon. Clichés are thus the
semantic structures' building blocks differing in shape, size and solidity which
explains why some are more popular, have a longer longevity or die out fast.
A systemic and systematic analysis of the formal and functional properties of
clichés finds that they are used because they require less effort to
be remembered, this due to the use of mnemonic devices such as redundancy, rhymes,
rhythm and metaphors.
The article is organized as follows: The first section shows that clichés
have distinctive formal and semantic features which were previously unknown
to linguists. Section two discusses the origin of clichés and shows that
their sources are very diverse.
Section three shows that the majority of clichés are metaphors and illustrates
their crucial role in cognition.
Section four explains why mainstream linguistics has neglected the study of
metaphors and why it should give them the attention that they rightly deserve.
Section five gives some examples which show the toxicity of clichés to
the mind.
The last section shows how clichés as metaphors are responsible for collective
memory and identity, give insight into how the mind works, make complex concepts
understandable and relieve space for memory storage and retrieval.
A cliché is a linguistic expression which is overused. Although the
majority of these already made structures are phrases and even complete sentences,
single words also such as nirvana 'paradise', mantra 'slogan/leitmotif', Mecca
'a tourist a place that attracts people who share the same interest', guru 'expert'
,morph 'transform/change', to compartmentalize, to underscore
occur as
clichés because of this overuse. In the academic circles, narrative,
to debunk the myth, to be at the cutting edge, paradigm shift are very popular
right now. In the news to day, weapons of mass destruction, breeding grounds
for terrorism, to break the rules of engagement , road map, the fog of war,
exit strategy, outsourcing, to metastasize into, Schadenfreude
are used
almost everyday.
Background to the project:
When I started the study of clichés I didn't know that they were going
to have any value to linguistic theory or offer insight into the study of mind.
In their essays, my students were using a lot of them partly due to the fact
that some sentences were leafed verbatim from the internet or other publications.
As a concerned teacher I wanted my students to use their own words and use critical
thinking. What shocked me also was the fact that the language mavens, journalists
and book and art reviewers were using clichés as well. Thus all good
books are a breath of fresh air, a good play or concert is a coup de force or
virtuoso performance, a good wine has personality, complexity and character,
etc. That is how I started a crusade to hunt them down and collect them and
give them to students so that they don't use them in their essays anymore. These
enemies that I passionately hated, ended up becoming my friends. This is now
a major chapter on my book on metaphors.
These clichés have been collected from the New York Times over a period
of four years and looked up in the search engine, Google, to check their frequency.
For instance, the internet search of the cliché we stand on the shoulders
of giants used in political speeches found 1,950,000 cases, something is rotten
in the state of such as something is rotten in the state of California or something
is rotten in the state of California or something is rotten in the state of
higher education came up with 3,020, 000 results , if it walks like a duck,
quarks like a duck, looks like a duck then it must be a duck used mostly by
politicians to mock their colleagues has 51,300 entries. This chapter should
not be considered as a dictionary of clichés and it is the reason why
they have not been listed alphabetically or explained. A generous body of examples
are provided to convince doubters how important they are in everyday language
use and in mental processes.
I. The Structure of Clichés.
At first glance, clichés don't seem to have any particular formal property
because they occur in any style from the prosaic to the poetic in any type of
structure as simple nouns, full sentences, verb phrases, noun phrases, adverbial
phrases, prepositional phrases, etc. This also might explain why thed did attract
interest from linguists.
Full sentences clichés:
You know what I mean, there is trouble brewing, there is something in the wind,
there is/was no love lost between them, it is nothing to boast about, it is
not worth the paper it is written on, there is more in it that meets the eye,
it is not an open secret, that goes without saying, there is no doubt in my
mind, X died on the line of duty, what you see is what you get, the rest is
history, days are numbered, it is simple as that, I could hardly believe my
eyes, a little bird told me, one thing led to another, the bill sailed through
the senate floor, the helicopters combed the mountain looking for X, the stakes
are high, now let's go down to business, it was like manna from heaven, the
ball is in your court, it was love on the first sight, s/he was somebody who
couldn't hurt a fly, X needs no introduction, there are other fish in the sea,
time will tell, the time stood still, it doesn't ring a bell, the genie is out
of the bottle, it is easier said than done, it seems like it is the right thing
to do, facts speak for themselves, time is ripe, the poll has a margin of sampling
error of plus or minus X percentage points, the sky is the limit, it remains
to be seen, the emperor/king has no clothes, something gets/got lost in the
translation, the hell has broken loose, X doesn't hold water, X is a hard sale,
it is too good to be true, enough is enough, it's a jungle out there, history
is repeating itself, we have lost the battle we have not lost the war, silence
is golden, it's a totally different ball game, so far so good, it's an open
question, it's a long way to go, there is no free lunch, money talks, imitation
is the sincerest way of flattery , X is not rocket science, you don't have to
have a rocket scientist, the beauty is the of he beholder, it is still anybody´s
guess, it was love at first sight, the investigation suffered from lack of resources,
the death toll climbed/rose, the case is pending, names of victims were not
being released because many family members had not been notified, X will not
be the same, it was an easy feast, emotions are running high, there is something
in the air, X is anybody's guess, the fighting broke out, the rest is history,
X should come as no surprise, East meets West, nothing is set in stone, the
war broke out between X and Y, there is a hitch, , a picture is worth a thousand
words., X are from Mars and Y are from Venus, there are no easy answers, no
man is an island, history repeats itself, the talk is cheap, it's business as
usual, it's a no-brainer, no love is lost between X and Y, it's a dream come
true, the buck stops here, if truth be told, these are no laughing matters,
let's go down to business, the road to heaven is filled with good intentions,
X is here to stay, patience is wearing thin, chickens are coming home to roost
, you ain't seen nothing yet, don't get me wrong, it's the dream come true,
extraordinary times (situations) call for extraordinary measures (solutions),
there is no question in my mind , the time is ripe, tomorrow is another day,
let's wait and see, God knows only what , all hell broke loose, they are two
sides of the same coin, there is another side to the coin, the X clock is ticking,
X's heart goes to Y, first things first, truth is the first casualty of war,
the list goes on, the lord works in mysterious ways, time is of the essence,
it is an idea whose time has come, time heals, let's put it this way, it's too
early to tell, you can't get your cake and eat it too, it's no big deal, that
is out of the question., X never ceases to amaze me, X is here to stay, there
is no free ride/lunch, it was a poor choice of words, it was stupid; it is a
fair game, the heads are going to start rolling, the day/night is still young,
X is a testament to Y, X is another case in point, thanks but no thanks, everything
is up in the air, wake up and smell the coffee, nothing succeeds like success,
the case is still pending, it's not over until it's over, it's a match made
in haven, legend has it , it's too good to be true, X is my middle name, here
we go again, life imitates art, the point is well taken, it's a different ballgame,
thank(s) for asking, nothing could be further from the truth, it's no small
feat, X could not be reached for comment, the worst is yet to come, so far so
good, nothing could be further from the truth, the pendulum swung from X to
Y, put up or shut up, will the real X please stand up, there is a bumpy road
ahead, there is still a long way to go, there is there there, what goes around
comes around, you get the picture, I am so hungry I could eat a horse, nothing
would ever be the same again, legend has it that X, X is here to stay, X was
somebody who would not hurt a fly, it couldn't haved been further from the truth,
let's face it, that/it remains to be seen, histories are written by the winners,
absolute power corrupts absolutely, that was then. the hell broke loose, there
you go, that's the bottom line, the truth will set you free, there is a thin
line between X and Y, X pales in comparison to Y, nothing was/is/will be lost
in translation, it is a world s/he/they knew too well, that's only half the
story, it's plain and simple, the situation is spinning out of control, it's
an idea whose time has come, history is written by victors, X is not getting
any younger, are you out of your mind?, to hell with it, it's X whose time has
come, the silence was so thick that you could cut it, one picture is worth a
thousand words , it's beyond anybody's wildest dreams, there is (no) sight at
the end of the tunnel, he married his high-school sweetheart, it's business
as usual, let the chips fall where they may, sound familiar?, it's as simple
as that/it is that simple, God works in mysterious ways, the ends justify the
means, the buck stops at X, victory grows out the barrel of the gun, stay tuned,
X is around the corner, let me put it this way, hasta la vista,baby, money talks,
if you've got one X you've got them all, there are no easy answers,that's the
million-dollar question, excuse the cliché,
and bingo!, the catch?,
the running joke is X, there is (no) elephant in the room., what's good for
X is good for Y; when X gets a cold , Y gets pneumonia,. the difference is more
a matter of style than of substance; no way Jose, patience is wearing thin,
X is not worth the paper it is written on, similarities don't end there, you
get the idea, don't even think about it, X is a metaphor for Y, X is Y's middle
name, if you are going to talk the talk, you better walk the walk, Rome was
not built in one day, there is no time like the present, time heals all wounds,
better later than never, there is no place like home, money doesn't grow on
trees, money makes the world go round, money doesn't bring happiness, what goes
around comes around, what is good for the goose is good for the gander, don't
pee on me and tell me it's raining, the buck stops here, there's no such a thing
as a free lunch, you cannot have your cake and eat it too, legend has it that
S, it's much a a do about nothing, nothing is carved in stone, it was the final
straw that S, X is on the horizon, different circumstances requrire new methods/tactics.,
X is an inexact science, it doesn't work that way, there's no love lost between
X and Y, X and Y are day and night, th emperor doesn't have any clothes, X was/is
out of the question, the winds of change are sweeping the world, it is only
part of the picture, you are the Man
Similes
Mad as hops, mad as a wet hen, mad as hell, neat as bandbox, clear as a whistle,
cool as cucumber, right as rain, tight as the bark on a tree, plain as pikestaff,
deaf as an adder, flat as a pancake, poor as a church mouse, to sell like hotcakes,
as American as apple pie, to be as nasty as one comes. to sound like a broken
record, free as a bird, to be as secret as the formula of Coca Cola, to be tough
as nails..
Verb phrases
to be on a higher moral ground, to be up for grabs, to open the window, to
leave the door open, to kill the bill , to tighten the noose (around the neck),
to send shock waves, to leave (no) room, to keep at arm's length, to drop the
other shoe, to take matters into one's hands, to send chills running down the
spine, to be down to earth, to be off in the clouds, to be behind bars, to leave
no stone unturned, to know which way the wind blows, to follow suit, to get/jump
on X bandwagon, to pass the hat, to be born with a silver spoon in one's mouth,
to make one's mouth water, to make oneself scarce, to make one's blood boil,
to make ends meet, to be lulled to false sense of security, to look facts in
the face, to cry wolf, to rock the boat, to show one's true colors, to start
from scratch, to hatch a plan/a scheme, to have a short/long shelf life, to
fade away from memory, to offer another piece to the puzzle, to hold the key,
to have second thoughts., to fly in the face of, to blow out of proportion,
to float/entertain an idea, to land a job/role, to pick a fight, to push the
boundaries, to push the envelope, to kill the messenger, to touch delicate nerves,
to flatly deny/reject, to unleash violence, to reign supreme, to add a strange
twist to the tale, to make a long story short.. to gather/gain momentum, to
wear X as a badge of honor, to set the record straight, to know full well. to
set a bad/dangerous precedent, to make X an offer s/he cannot refuse, to develop
the sixth sense, to use X as a whipping boy, to mix business with pleasure,
to be confined in the dustbin of history, to give credit where credit is due,
to be at an all-time high, to dwell on the past, to crack (self-deprecating)
jokes , to sacrifice X to the altar of Y, to circle the square, to make front
page news, to have a skeleton in the closet, to slip through the cracks, to
X under the table, to stand on the shoulders of giants, to sink into oblivion,
not to take no for an answer , to cut a long story short, to live in a parallel
universe, to give X one's best shot, to let the genie out of the bottle, to
pay a debt to society, to rise through the ranks, to bet one's two cents.
Noun Phrases
NN or AdjN
Exhibit A, plan B, paper trail, face value, pipe dream, zero tolerance, a shelf
life, encyclopedic knowledge, a walking encyclopedia, a good Samaritan, umbrella
organization, red herring, big shot, fat cat, a hot potato, a stirring controversy,
black sheep, hit list, trump card, the conventional wisdom, sluggish economy,
young Turks, circumstantial evidence , moral bankruptcy, a judgment call, a
one-night stand, double standards, radar screen, political spectrum, twilight
zone, patron saint, sugar daddy, salad days, landmark decision, bench mark,
a foregone conclusion, legal limbo, motivational speaker, a dream house, wee
hours, a hard sell, a basket case, a wake-up call, uncharted territory, a moot
point, the missing link, collective memory/unconscious, joy ride, white elephant,
to be caught flat-footed, point blank, telltale sign, maiden voyage, a law-abiding
citizen, knee-jerk reaction, a vibrant economy, wishful thinking, zero-sum game,
rampant/entrenched corruption, fever pitch, vigilante justice, maverick politician,
mercurial leader, bruised ego, a straw man argument, a living symbol, the inner
circle, exit strategy, vigilante justice, a twilight zone, a tough sell, rhetorical
question, erratic behavior, social commentary, sublimal message, formative years,
close-knit community, abject poverty, big question, a stiff sentence, a missed
opportunity, career trajectory, a high school sweetheart, a tough sale, track
record, soft spot, a resounding no, banana republic, a shining example, open/closed
society, thinning air, a fresh look, a pea size X, life size, gag order, a ragtag
army, a cheap shot, a flash point, reality check, a rhetorical question, a defining
moment, a sleepy town, the old guard, a straight arrow, moral relativism, identity
crisis, power vacuum, an umbrella organization, a rosy picture, ivory tower,
mood swings, a bruised ego, a landmark decision, window dressing, cosmetic changes,
a status symbol, a conspiracy theory, a last-ditch effort/attempt, a golden
age, glory days, a basket case, a color-blind society, a subliminal message,
a rocky start/beginning, loose change, a leathery face, a cavalier attitude
,a silent majority, an unsung hero, an elder statesman, a cottage industry,
the puzzle missing piece , a freak accident, swing voters, an exit strategy,
a laundry list, a time-honored X, a card-carrying member of X, a has-been X,
young urban professionals, a watchdog group, an intricate web, abject poverty
, an acquired test, a twilight zone, gut feeling, an absent-minded professor,
a midlife crisis, a kitchen cabinet , a knee-jerk reaction, an occupational
hazard, in the good old days, a seven-figure salary, for an undisclosed sum,
an educated guess, an acquired taste, a struggling artist, a symbiotic relationship,
one night stand, seed money, business acumen, moral compass, punishing weather/temperature,
spiritual journey
N+N
a chain of events/command,, the grapes of wrath, a jack of all trades, the
call of nature, a piece of the pie, a thing of the past, rules of engagement,
the survival of the fittest, the swing of the pendulum, a breath of fresh air,
the winds of change, the corridors of power, the halls of the academe, a train
of thought, a highly respected member of the community, center of gravity, a
memorandum of understanding, the framers of the constitution, a change of heart
, a clash of civilization, a culture of impunity, miscarriage of justice, a
butt of jokes, a sphere of influence, a frame of reference, a leap of faith,
the fog of war, the leader of the free world, a comedy of errors.
A closer look, however, reveals something different. Like proverbs, some clichés.
use poetic devices such as sound repetition, meter, rhyme and rhythm. The ones
that are shown below use consonant repetition as a rich body of examples illustrate:
Troubled/turbulent/tumultuous/trying/tough/trying times, sunny skies, towering
task, mighty mountain, military might, military muscle, rave reviews, wet winters,
sweet sixteen, pet project, epic proportion, sorry state, sexy senior citizen,
full force, a feminine feel, high hopes, bloody business, to be on a collision
course, crash course, position paper, bad blood, barroom brawl, bare bones,
pitch perfect, added advantage, vested interest, the wild west, the whole wide
world, bully pulpit, , to stand in stark contrast, stony silence, feeding frenzy,
double-digit inflation, father figure, building blocks, polar opposite, star-studded,
bursting bubbles, express purpose ,slippery slope, baby boomers, a stepping
stone, peak performance, public policy, partisan politics , free flow, peer
pressure, pencil pusher, hard-hat, beer-belly, blood bath, family feud, proud
parents, worldly wisdom, big business, to fan fears, midsummer madness, a brisk
breeze, helping hand, temper tantrum, street-smart, road rage, beast of burden,
sordid sex scandal, propaganda ploy, fist fight, a sorry sight, be caught flat-footed,
mild-mannered, far-fetched, far-flung, star-struck, fatally flawed, to make
a mountain out of a molehill, to shrug shoulders, to make amends, make no mistakes,
to agree to disagree, to be larger than life, to pay the price, to forgive but
not forget, to sail the seven seas, to compound problems, to loom large, to
wage war, to bear the brunt, to hope against hope, to set in stone, to set the
stage, to become the talkt of the town, to be waiting in the wings, to fan the
flames, to pull the plug, to dig deep, to set off the storm, to take the world
by the storm, to be in deep debt, to set off a storm, to pull punches, to pinch
pennies, to rob Peter to pay Paul, to pay the piper, to pick up pieces, to put
your money where your mouth is, to go to the dogs, in the belly of the beast,
, in the wee hours, to add fuel to the fire, not to mince matters, to put pen
to paper, to wend one's way, to hammer the point home, to beat about the bush,
to have another fish to fry ,to rocket the ruckus, to stand the test of time,
to hold one's head high, to go down the drain, to bring to the brink, talk turkey,
to take the toll, code of conduct, words of wisdom, back to basics , to feel
free to, the turn of the tide, the wings of the wind, cast of characters, a
piece of the pie, close as a clam, when push comes to shove, derring-do, dry
as dust, tempest in a teaspoon, all in all, the world will not willingly let
die, fit as a fiddle, sure as shooting , to deal a deep blow, fast forward,
a bully boy, to take to the streets, a dime a dozen, man's inhumanity to man,
taxation without representation, to lend a helping hand, signed, sealed and
delivered, a clarion call, rolling hills, sweet smell of success, eggshell ego,
deadbeat dads, to stand sentry, to put two and two together, to fall flat, a
tangled tale, sunny skies, melancholic melody, wailing walls, for practical
purposes, Garden of Eden, a fertile field, war wary, to quell questions, in
a split second, litmus test, a role reversal, a terror attack, to settle scores,
to dig deep, to cut to the core, poison pill, a bitter battle, to stand for
principles over political expediency, to hit home, the ticking of time, poor
performance, to stand in stark contrast, to put profit before the people, cash
cows , to let go of one's ego, dying days of colonialism, to take the town by
the storm, to go into free fall, to put up a smoke screen, a penny pincher,
to run rampant, to run errands, a chorus of critics, a sorry state, mutatis
mutandis, to gain ground, cause for concern, a success story, to stand in sharp
contrast, a siren song, pen pal, the blame game, to ruffle feathers, from rags
to riches, from dusk to dawn, an entrepreneurial enterprise, to be in full flowers,
to stand the challenges of a changing world , the magic of the moment, purple
prose, a pulse-pounding prose,sound asleep, to be the name of the game, from
the prosaic to the poetic, a subliminal stimulus, a disastrous disaster, to
have a knack for being at the door when opportunity knocks, vice than a virtue,
nature versus nurture, a raucous caucus, whimsical wit, to ponder a problem,
to stand still, to sit still, to be tart-tongued, time tested, penny wise but
pound foolish, to tackle a task., chump change, to put a pen to the pad, sleepy
summer seasons, robber baron, draft dodge, stump speech, to blur boundaries,
to swear like a sailor, sound of silence, to take another twist, to take a heavy
toll, to take to task, deadbeat dad, too little too late, nigthtime is the right
time..
The following binomial expressions and reduplicated forms were discussed in
Kimenyi ( ) as examples of syntagmatic phonetic iconicity.
Battered and bruised, boom and doom, boon and bust, huffing and bluffing, huffing
and puffing, tried and true, to wax and wane, free and fair, death and destruction,
out of all scotch and notch, play ducks and drakes with, thread and thrum, left
high and dry, to go to rack and ruin, odds and ends, bread and butter, spick
and span, fuss and feathers, discuss birds and bees, down and dirty, between
the devil and the deep blue sea, by hook and by crook, high days and holidays,
to hum and haw, kith and kin, last but not least, with all might and maim, to
sink or swim, wishy-washy, to publish or perish, in times of stress and strain,
neither hide nor hair, without rhyme or reason, part and parcel, the sum and
substance, fauna and flora, friends and foes, from tip to tail, to act as judge
and jury, trials and tribulations, wild and wooly, prunes and prisms, come hell
or high water, in the dim and distant past, to wine and dine, make fish of one
and flesh of another, plain as a pikestaff and prisms, to ooh and aah, flotsam
and jetsam, hugger-mugger, loosey-goosey, concise and precise, the best and
the brightest, the last but not the least, hodgepodge, mishmash, hanky-panky,
hocus-pocus, itsy-bitsy, every twist and turn, to fuss and fume, a down-and-dirty
job, to weather a gathering storm., to litter and glitter, do or die, scope
and scale, boom and bust, to hustle and bustle, to coddle and cuddle, the arts
and the crafts, command and control, scale and scope, checks and balances, you
put up or you shut up, slowly but surely, the lore and lure, dribs and drabs,
the scale and the scope, to be both judge and jury, dilapidation and decay,
.to collude and collide, rags-to-riches success, style and substance, lean and
mean, manner and mien , zero and zilch, remote and removed, to transmit and
transmut, flailties and foibles, by omission and commission, glitz and glamour,
nature-nurture debate, to falter and fail, odds and ends, sham and shame, bland
and blunt, between and betwixt, to flare and fade, the bling and the bliss,
the young and yearning, to be blocked and blockaded, to huff and puff, to slice
and dice, the sacred and the secular, surf and turf , the bits and bytes, revolutionary
and revelatory , brunt and brawny, habitats and habits, to sample and savor,
to flit and filter , power and privilege, angst and anger, brainy and brawny,
prophets of gloom and doom, lore and gore, plander and pundering, (an era of)
change and challenge, flashy and fleshy, fuzzy-wuzzy, hominy and homilies, charm
and chutzpah, , to sniff, sip and and spit, sobs and slaps, all vim and vigor,
with nerve and verve, anger and anguish, lean and lethal, slicing and dicing,
peculiar and particular, cheeky and cheerful, minutely and meticulously,to hoot
and holler, to rant and rave, cheers and jeers, the lore and lure, in tone and
tempo, vice and virtue, wary and weary, fears and fixations, whim and whimper..
Paired expressions
By leaps and bounds, ins and outs, to dot one's i's and cross one's t's, land
of milk and honey, the rank and file, to leave high and dry, a give and take,
far and wide, fair and square, each and every, to fight foot and nail, to mind
one's q's and p's, to all intents and purposes, body and soul, on pins and needles,
in black and white, to play fast and loose, checks and balances, bits and pieces,
movers and shakers, time and time again, in this day and age, betwixt and between,
a joy and delight, to follow the spirit and the letter of, to move heaven and
earth, to be neck and neck, when all is said and done, to come in all shapes
and sizes, cock and bull stories, to win hearts and minds, a chicken-and-egg
question/puzzle, time and again, by and large, once and for all, lo and behold,
rough and tumble, aiding and abetting, to be alive and kicking, better late
than sorry, all nooks and crannies, nuts and bolts, to cut and paste, (a widening
gulf between) the haves and the have-nots, on-again-off-again relationship,
to wait and see, to say it loud and clear, to wear and tear, salt-and-pepper
hair/beard, to ebb and flow, by trial and error, facts and figures, to play
hide and seek, the ups and downs, hide and seek, to see in black and white,
the rise and fall of empire, the breadth and depth of, up and down, back and
forth, on and off, to weigh the pros and the cons, pump and circumstance, pure
and simple, literally and figuratively, to be eyes and ears, through trial and
error, to play cat and mouse, in fits and starts, approach/strategy, the fits
and the starts, at home and abroad, from now and then to be sick and tired,
with pomp and circumstance/pageantly, a day in and a day out, hawks and doves,
the letter and the spirit of, the land of milk and honey, a charts-and-graphs
presentation ,to be sick and tired, null and void ,an either or proposition,
speedy and full recovery, the rise and fall of X , in ways large and small,
the ins and outs, in ways large and small, pop-and-mom businesses, cloaks and
daggers, , a cat-and-mouse game, pros and cons, a cock-and-bull story, to rain
cats and dogs, wild and crazy, the hue and cry, hit-and-run accident, the ins-and-outs
of, to, to cut and run, to be up and running, the pros and cons, average Joe
and Jane, to shock and awe, a land of milk and honey, to be straight and narrow,
a heart of gold and a will of steel, to offer sticks and carrots, to be night
and day, to compare apples and oranges, political longstanding and mudslinging,
wheeling and dealing, the heart and soul of, on a wing and a prayer, a nickle-and-dime
X, from cradle to grave, wear and tear, rain or shine
.
The use of rhythm, rhyme is universal and found in all languages when it has
to do with cliches, proverbs, slogans , commercials, bumper stickers, headline
news as the following ones from Latin, Italian and French show:
homo homine lupus (man is a wolf to a man), urbi and orbi (to the city (Rome)
and the to world) an expression the Vatican uses when addressing the Catholic
Church community, traduttore traditore (the translator is a traitor), le droit
de sang et le droit du sol (right of blood and right of soil) meaning rights
due to French citizens due to birth on the French soil and French parents.
The following are special because the qualifying adjective follows the head
noun.
Rock solid, lily white, crystal clear, sky high, snow white, razor/paper thin,
skin deep, midnight/ocean/navy/sky blue, power hungry, poverty stricken, medium
rare,time-tested, shell shocked, heir apparent, user friendly, trigger happy,
drug free, prince charming, body politic .
Redundancy, paradox, contrast, synonymy, emphasis, paraphrase, play on words
and other rhetorical devices can also make a phrase a cliché, as the
following examples show.
Good evil, loud colors, a deafening silence, a noisy silence, poetic justice,
more often than not, second to none, to know a great thing when one sees it,
all things being equal, in less than no time, untold advantages, to be one's
worst enemy, an accident waiting to happen, to take on a life of one's own,
to mean well, honest mistake, a case of mistaken identity, to tell it like it
is, an offer you cannot refuse, to beg to differ, to agree to disagree, to agree
without being disagreeable, to call a spade a spade, zero tolerance, the sum
total, root cause, the tail end, the end result/product, sum total, to up the
ante, rear end, weapons of mass destruction, if the truth be told, to give the
benefit of the doubt, to make an offer one cannot refuse, to talk the talk and
to walk the walk, under the watchful eye of, to draw to a close, through word
of mouth, the first/last leg of X's journey, spitting image, verbal diarrhea,
intellectual masturbation, to win/lose thebattle not the war, there is no there
there, to out-X X (ex.to out-google Google), the beginning of the end, a six-figure
salary, to thumb the nose, to weather the storm., to know next to nothing, to
be catch as catch can, man's inhumanity to man, the more things change the more
they remain the same, to spell trouble/disaster, to cook books ..
What makes clichés stand out, however, are not the type of syntactic
structure they occur in but rather the types of metaphors that are used. The
majority of clichés consist indeed of metaphors. These ones are more
vivid, graphic and picturesque.
II. The use of metaphors
One of the ways expressions become clichés is the presence of metaphors
and metonymies which draw attention such as hyperboles using superlatives and
diminutives.
A rising star, meteoric rise, to go ballistic, the business empire, the media
tycoon/mogul, the drug barons, the oil dynasty, basketball superstar, drug czar,
astronomical figure, monumental/colossal task, sea change, mammoth debt, the
corporate giant, a giant corporation, a multi-million X empire, the king of
rock and roll, a film goddess, a welfare queen, business titan, a war zone,
cutthroat struggle, heaven on earth, stratospheric ascent, a media behemoth,
sky high ,a needle in the haystack, to sink low, gold mine, a swollen ego, to
grow/increase exponentially, to inflate one's ego, to lay to rest, to sound
the alarmt, something earthshakingly important, to trim the budget, character
assassination, to dig one's own grave, to steal somebody's heart, to be out
of one's mind, an island of X in a sea of Y/an X island in a Y sea, to sit on
a gold mine,a snake-oil salesmanto offer the sun and the moon, a dog-eat-dog
worldloan sharks, vulture investors, thunderous roars, a gazillion times, to
spread the tentacles,a world-class X, filthy rich, to make baby steps, to skate
on thin ice, a razor/paper thin victory, , a drop in the bucket, X is a death
sentence, to live in parallel universes, a marathon session, a million-dollar
smile, that's a $64,000 question, to eat somebody alive, to stab somebody in
the back, a calamity/disaster of biblical proportions, a train reck, political
roller coaster, to hijack a political process/agenda
etc.
Dramatization
to go to each other's throat, to gouge each other's eyes out, to walk on eggshells,
to drive off the cliff (into something totally different), to run around with
one's hair on fire, to launch somebody into orbit, to spin one's wheels in X,
everybody's jaws dropped, to cut the silence with a knife, skyrocketing prices,
galloping inflation, ballooning budgetary deficit, to explode with rage, to
laugh one's head off, to declare war, to unleash wrath, , to take a quantum
leap, to hang by the thread, to walk on tightrope , to take the plunge, to open
X floodgates, screaming ties, to be caught with the pants down, don't pee on
me and pretend it's raining. .
Thus political changes or scandals are described using natural disaster metaphors:
winds of change, landslide victory, slippery slope, to open political floodgates,
to stem political tide, political earthquake/tornado/hurricane//rainstorms/snowstorm/tsunami/twister/avalanche/tempest/cyclone/floodwaters/deluge/windfall,
to stir (up) a political thunderstorm, to ignite political firestorms, seismic
shift, earth-shaking X, an ideological firestorm, a rising tide of troubles,
a swelling sea of troubles.
The following follow the same principle. The exaggeration shown by superlatives
or diminutives as well as expressions which use a vivid description are found
in many of the majority of clichés listed below.
to climb the social ladder, self-fulfilling prophecy, to take a fresh look,
to be hell bent, to be filled to capacity, deep-seated, last-ditch effort, a
textbook case, to be a music to the ear, all walks of life, to be the name of
the game, hermetically sealed, Alice in the wonderland, in the dead of night,
to have a name recognition, sibling rivalry, catalyst for change, to scoff at
the idea, lesser evil, tender age, at the 11th hour, a gentlemen's agreement,
to be fair game, the beginning of an end, to eat one's heart out, a dream word/house/team,
by any stretch of the imagination, soul searching, to have a domino effect,
celebrity craze, to brainstorm, to streamline, to cut a long story short, to
draw the line (in the sand), rebel without a cause, flat denial ,to walk a tightrope,
to fish in troubled waters, from A to Z, to throw one's weight behind X, to
make strange bedfellows, to give somebody the cold shoulder, to be hand in glove
with, a wolf in a sheep's clothing, to take by storm, to stem the tide, to pull
the strings, to be one's worst enemy, on the tip of one's tongue, to hold out
an olive branch, of that ilk, to tie the knot, not without reason, nothing to
boast about, not what you would call, to have a face lift, to be murdered in
cold blood, much ado about nothing, to do more harm than good, the mark of the
beast, to mastermind, the long arm of the law, to let the cat out of the bag,
not to let the grass grow under one's feet, to lend an ear, to lead a dog's
life, with the stroke of a pen, to gather dust, to be a good sport, to get into
a shouting match, to fall on deaf ears, to be very high on the agenda, jet-setting,
to have the upper hand, to teeter on the brink of, to exercize poor judgment,
foregone conclusion, body politic, twisted logic, to speak volumes, love at
first sight, to disappear into thin air, against incredible odds, to breathe
a sigh relief, a leap into the unknown ,to be set in motion, to give a shot
in the arm, to come home to roost, to set the record straight, to blur the lines,
to dismiss out of hand, to become a hotbed to, a new wrinkle, simply put, a
package deal, over the hill, like a cat on hot tin roof, to give a rubber stamp,
thumbs up, devil's advocate, to up the ante, from the horse's mouth, earmarked,
a cliff-hanger, to beef up, to gear up, to get one's foot in the door, a clean
slate, to go off on the right foot, get to first base, to pick up the pieces,
to pick up the threads, to hit the nail on the head, to stand on the shoulders
of giants, at daggers drawn/drawing, hell on wheels, to make no bones about
it, straight from the shoulder, to call one's shots, to cut the mustard, up
for grabs, to have scores to settle, to be a case in point, to make somebody
sick to the stomach, damaged goods, to address X head on, to seem mild by comparison,
to stop short of X-ing, take a deep breath, to be music to the ears, count to
ten, whitewash, sweep under the carpet, come to grips with, face the music,
a far cry, at loose ends, hand in glove, pot belly, highway robbery, cold feet,
five-finger, jailbird, the last straw that broke the camel's back, eavesdropper,
a fly on the wall, to shake the dust from one's feet, to hang on somebody's
sleeve, in the wind, a hard nut to crack, hard row to hoe, underdog, grass roots,
lose the thread, black sheep, hit list, pull strings, to have many strikes against
somebody, steep nose dive, to view with deep suspicion, to sink one's teeth
into, to X round-the-clock,a round-the-clock X, to hold somebody responsible,
once in a while, upscale/gated community, under somebody's thumb, to cry wolf,
window dressing, gunboat diplomacy, to be tight-lipped, to poke fun at, to put
back on track, to make a sharp right turn, to race against the clock, to jump-start,
potluck, fast buck, golden years, hard evidence, to reach one's zenith, to poke
one's nose into X's business, to burn the midnight oil, to start the wheel of,
to offer red meat, kitchen cabinet, to carry a heavy load (of courses), to have
a light schedule, ghost writer, to bite off more than once can chew, to spread
oneself thin, moonlighting, instant gratification, in the classic X tradition,
task force, to speak with one single voice, to pick up the mess, if walls could
talk, a firmly held belief, to send shock waves through, to receive a rock star's
reception, sublimal messages, calm before the storm, halcyon days, second-class
citizens, to hold one's ground, bigwig, to spill the beans, a drug czar, a drug
kingpin, in the long run, cut it close, to hit the nail on the head, to be between
a rock and a hard place, to be in deep water, to be in hot water, to put on
the spot, to be in the pipeline, sprawling city, rampant corruption, to root
out corruption, to throw one's weight behind, to fly in the face of, to remain
true to X, the-one-size-fits-all X, to paint X with broad brsuh strokes, to
bite the bullet, to have on the tip of one's tongue, to ring a bell, to be out
of the woods, to clean one's act, a high school drop out, a high school sweetheart,
reality television, room for change, since the dawn of humanity, to drive the
point home, to send mixed signals, sour grapes, Russian roulette, to reinvent
the wheel, to keep the flame alive, to pull the rug under somebody, to rule
with an iron fist, egghead, highbrow, a skeleton in the closet, to dig one's
grave, to paddle one's own canoe, yellow journalism, peeping Tom, run-of-the-mill,
top billing, upper crust, to catch fire, to drop charges, to throw out the case,
politically correct, guilty by association, to make both ends meet, to have
the last laugh, to lend on one's feet, to turn up trumps, to keep one's fingers
crossed, old wives' tale, be taken aback, to smell a rat, to shoot the breeze,
verbal diarrhea, to hold at bay, to the bitter end, to stem the tide, to pull
someone's leg, to keep a low profile, to hit below the belt, to drive up the
wall, fall guy, god digger, guinea pig, , meager salary, a fat check account,
to be on the ropes, to grease the wheels, if the past is any guide, to tell
it like it is, to take under one's wings, not to take no as an answer, to weather
storms,navel gazer, to have a bone to pick, to have an ax to grind, to hit a
jackpot, a wild-goose chase, to square the circle, to blow a fuse, to blow off
steam, to hit the ceiling/roof, slow burn, sacred cow, the cat calling the kettle
black, to go overboard , to get a shot in the arm, to get/sink one's teeth into,
to add insult to injury, to be in good hands, behind the scenes, cannot believe
one's own eyes, beyond any (possible) shadow of doubt, to wear many hats, beneath
contempt, born under a lucky sky, the old boys' network, to leave with a bad
taste in the mouth, to be business as usual, by the same token, the best-case
scenario, a back-up plan, to make a cameo appearance, by word of mouth, silent
majority, foot soldiers, a dress rehersal, dark horse, to stand on the sidelines,
to draw to a close, to be a blessing in disguise, a publicity stunt, to stay
the course, to lift the embargo/economic sanctions, to have far-reaching effects,
a flat denial, from the cradle to the grave, formative years, heavy burden (on
the shoulders), to carry the cross, first-hand information, second-hand, on
the other hand, on one hand, to seize the moment, to be a step ahead, to stretch
as far as the eye can see, to miss/rock the boat, to entertain thoughts, a close-knit
community, to deal a (heavy) blow, simply put, revolving door, glass ceiling,
window of opportunity, publicity stunt, moral relativism, second-class citizen,
blue collar, to eat one's heart out, to gain the ground, to drive the point
home, to fall into place, a tired word, to give the devil his due, to pendulum-swing,
to live a peripatetic life, to go to the extreme, a heated argument, historic
occasion/moment, in a nutshell, a last ditch effort, to ride the wave, to kill
in cold blood, in the heat of the moment, in the nick of time, to be in the
public eye, to be in the same boat, in the twinkling of an eye, not one/a single
iota, the lesser of two evils, guilty by association, to be a sign of the times,
to be/play the devil's advocate, the lesser of two evils, to take a hands-on
approach, to be/fall into the wrong hands, to keep one's eyes open, to keep
one's mouth shut, to kill two birds with one stone, not to know somebody from
Adam to Eve, to know full well, a law-abiding citizen, to leave much to be desired,
not to have a leg to stand on, the soaring of mercury, a moot point, s/he is
not what you would call, to hold out an olive branch, not to be on speaking
terms, on more than one occasion, to have one foot in the grave, out of the
blue, an outstanding figure, to play with fire, a four-letter word, forbidden
fruit, rotten to the core, from all walks of life, great masters, to see red,
to sell like hot cakes, to sell one's soul, to show one's teeth, to stab in
the back, to take one's life in one's hands, to take the words out somebody's
mouth, to be taken aback, to thirst for somebody's blood, to throw dust in somebody's
eyes, to be torn asunder, untimely end, to welcome with open arms, to wear trousers,
to vanish into thin air, to wash one's hand, to waste one's breath, a tip of
the iceberg, the knight in the shining armor, to bring X to its knees, to bring
X back to its feet, to come into focus, a sugar daddy, to start from scratch,
to come up with, to pick up where one has left off, to cover a lot of territory,
to pin down, to tip the balance, to bring to the negotiating table, sluggish
economy, victory by the ballot not the bullet, turning point, in the first place,
bear/bull market, to have close ties, cold war, to bite the bullet, persona
non grata, pro bono, to serve a fig leaf, the chain of command, public discourse,
to have certain misgivings, to take shape, to go to great lengths, record breaking,
to pay lip service, in one's own right, to thumb one's nose, to give a hands-on
experience, think tank, personality cult, to have a photographic memory, side
effects, to break the ice, as is often the case, as dust settles, gentleman's
agreement, quintessentially American, tame by comparison, to ring hollow, to
keep in the dark, brainchild, a slap in the face, walking time bomb, against
the backdrop of, room for improvement, room to maneuver, to show one's true
colors, to be ahead of one's time, to be in full swing, a household name, colorful
life, sweeping changes, driving force, keynote speaker, to take/be under the
wing of, to draw a line, to be as American as pumpkin, spin doctor, to clear
clean hands, to muddy waters, to be the name of the game, baking sun, high moral
ground, to be down to earth, dashed hopes, media savvy, to name names, to pick
the brains of, to get the genie out of the bottle, wishful thinking, mean street,
to take on a life of one's own, to welcome with open eyes, odd couple, dysfunctional
family, government mouthpiece, trouble-shooter, or for that matter, narrow-minded,
loophole, to dim prospects, to break new ground, to make no bones about, tongue
in cheek, to pick up momentum, to sound like a broken record player, outgoing
personality, to fall into the wrong hands,, to bury X in bowels of Y, to break
the circle of poverty, culture wars, kangaroo court, to spin one's whels, antebellum
South, middle age crisis, to let bygones be bygones, to X at the 11th hour,
as the end drew near, to drive something home, crown jewel, to open (old) wounds,
to heal wounds, pockets of resistance, food for thought, to bend rules, to draw
a line in the sand, to be in somebody's shoes, to have skeletons in the closet,
to have all eggs in one basket, a whole new ball game, a golden opportunity,
to provide ammunitions, to cut the (bureaucratic) red tape, to change one's
mind, to have something on the mind, to get out of one's mind, to have an open
mind, an open/closed society, quintessential American, a shoe-string budget,
a cautionary tale,bargaing chip, war chest, poster boy, to iron out differences,
to be right on target, to negotiate a lane, to call it quits, to set the ground
rules, to set X on on its downward spiral, to come to a negotiating table, (not)
to have it both ways, fair-weather friends, one-size-fit-all, to change hands,
to be ahead of the game, early warning signs, to take a hands-off approach,
to take X as a badge of honor, X would turn over one's grave, to take matters
into one's own hands, to deal a heavy blow, to be back to square one, trivial
pursuit, bear hug, to be out of one's mind, to lose a train of thought, to put
all one's eggs in one basket, to make an informed decision, to sound like a
broken record player, to fall from grace, the knight in a shining armor, to
give the benefit of the doubt, in a timely fashion, a textbook case/example,
a security blanket, biblical proportions, half-baked ideas, minute details,
as the dust settles, to have a field day, to be a sign of the time, a love-hate
relationship, to bring to the negotiating table, lightening rod, to muddy waters,
to raise a red flag, to break the ideological gridlock, to ring alarm bells,
to stick to principles, with all due respect, a heated debate, to have a field
day, to unearth evidence, prima facie evidence, bona fide citizen, to let loose
the dogs of war, to set against a backdrop of, to take somebody under one's
wings, to lay on the table, to stir controversy, to ride high, to run deep,
to have only oneself to blame, to put one's stamp on X, to play phone tugs,
outright rejection, the girl next door, to wrap tightly in secrecy, to be at
a loss with words, to have double standards, to give X a bad name, to live on
the margins of society,to come full circle, to collapse on one´s own weight,
time-honored tradition, to face the music, to give wide latitude, to be on full
display, to have a photographic memory, tdead wrong, dead on arrival, to hold
the key, to fall on hard times, as a last resort, (not) happen in a vacuum,
to fall into somebody´s hands, to stand on the shoulders of giants, to
tighten the noose (around somebody's neck), to send shivers down the spine,
to have a chilling effect, tort reforms, to read tea leaves, trigger happy,
in one's own right, if history is any guide, the man at the desk where the buck
stops, anything once could lay one's hands on, to be prohibitively expensive,
to give peace a chance, to learn the hard way, to pin one's hope on, to be ahead
of one's time, by the same token, to be X's wildest dream, to be up in the air,
a whipping boy, brute force, white flight, to be in the middle of nowhere, to
wear X as a badge of honor, dirty old man, a male chauvinist pig, to have a
track record, to be X's middle name, to prosecute to the fullest extent of the
law, to have a life of one's own, to look X into the face, to be ahead of one's
time, to be filled far beyond capacity, to be on the receiving end, graveyard
shift, to be left with more questions than answers, to X with surgical precision,
a wisecracking sidekick, to come in all stripes, other things being equal, splinter
groups, to put a human face on X, to be teetering on the edge/verge/brink of
war/collapse, to become an overnight X, under false pretenses, to break the
color barrier, X 101, in the great scheme of things, to follow X to its logical
conclusion, a one-size-fits-all X, No X in their right mind would X, to call
a spade a spade, to take with a grain of salt, X that Y love(s) to hate, a marriage
made in heaven, if X is any indication, it goes without saying that, X would
roll in their grave(s), in a no-man's land, to hit a record high, to X Y with
a human face, to be lost in translation, on the spur of the moment, to have
one's days numbered, to know a thing or two about X, to spoon-feed X information,
a hair-raising X, X's worst nightmare, to spin out to have X at one's fingerprints,
to come out of closet, to speak with one voice, to be sick to one's stomach,
X isn't in Y's vocabulary, to do the heavy lifting, a dead-end job, to spearhead
a revolution, to turn back the clock, to step out of X's shadow, by the turn
of the century, to be in the trenches, a favorite whipping boy, to put oneself
in X's shoes, ro roll in the grave, to ring a bell, to send into a tailspin,
to smooth the rough edges of X, a hot button issue, both sides of the political
spectrum, to be born with a silver spoon in themouth, a clean bill of health,
to be in red, to get your head in the game, to run the gamut from X to Y, to
drum up support for, to hold the purse's strings, to get one's act together,
to cover ground, to reach deep into one's pockets, a closely knit community,
the stars are aligned in favor of, arm-twisting X, to cherry pick, propoganda/rumor
mill, dirty word, thorny issue, mood boosting, social fabric, to take the unusual
step, to carry the day, to give a pink slip, to throw X to the wolves, to fall
through the cracks of, safety net, to take X to new heights, in the dead of
the night, to shower X with gifts, to choke on one's own vomit, to give a head
start, to step on somebody's toes, to fill somebody's shoes, to be dressed to
nine, to cloud the judgment, to crack a joke, to get what one deserves, to go
straight to the point, no strings attached, to turn in one's grave, being called
X by Y is like being called ugly by a frog
etc.
These metaphors vividly describe states or human activities: to put a final
touch (painting), to lay the ground work, to tighten the screws, (construction),
to raze to the ground (de-construction), low-key, to strike a note, to be out
of tune (music), dead end (driving), slap in the face (fighting), to be in the
trenches, to provide ammunitions, trigger and target, to be right on target,
the drumbeat of war, to be caught in the crossfire, (war), fair game, to fall
into a trap, (hunting), to keep the ball rolling (football), heavy weight/light
weight, to box somebody in the corner (boxing), to let off the hook, to catch
the big fish, to cast a wider net, to fish out information (fishing), to keep
one's head above the water, to keep afloat, (swimming), to run neck and neck
(running), to be at X's fingertips (piano playing), to pull the strings (puppets).
Gestures of course are source domains for these clichés: to raise one's
eyebrows, to scratch one's head, to shrug shoulders, to rub shoulders, to rub
elbows, to drug one's feet, to fold arms, to point fingers, to cross fingers,
to pat somebody on the back, to roll one's eyes, to tighten one's belt, to force
somebody´s hand, to tie the knot, to give thumbs up, to throw one's hands
up, to get out of hand , to roll up one's sleeves
III. The Origin of Clichés
These clichés come from different discourses: foreign languages, Greek
and Roman mythologies, the bible, European history, literature, idiomatic expressions,
proverbs, popular culture, advertisement, media, and journalistic lingo.
French, Latin and Italian
éminence grise, noblesse oblige, ménage a trios, déjà
vu, c'est la vie!, double entendre, enfant terrible, a je ne sais quoi, carte
blanche, bête noire, cause celebre, rapprochement, engagement, détente,
nouveau riche, raison d'être, coup de grace, femmes fatales, tour de force,
coup de grace, faux pas, de rigueur, joie de vivre, savoir-faire, laissez-faire,
coup de theatre, au contraire, agent provocateur,bons mots, bon vivant, a fait
accompli, roman a clef, terra incognita, casus belli, persona non grata, pro
bono, mutatis mutandis, modus operandi, deus ex machina, la dolce vita, prima
facie (evidence),à la X., idée fixe , grande dame, par excellence,
esprit de corps, nom de guerre, l'état, c'est moi.
French calques
Although English is a Germanic language, the majority of its vocabulary comes
from Latin and French. This is due to the 11th century Norman occupation. It
is also interesting to note that the loan-words don't only deal with referents
in the superstratum such as government, art, literature, religion, law, commerce,
military, science and technology but also to the substratum as well including
kinship terms such as family, parents, uncle, aunt, cousin, niece/nephew,
English has kept the French expressions but translated some of them into English.
To take the bull by the horns (prendre le taureau par les cornes), to build
castles on sand (batir les chateaux sur le sable), the ball is in your court
(la balle est dans votre camp), to put the cart before the ox (mettre la charrue
devant le boeuf), to give the green light (donner le feu vert), rising star
(etoile montante), a striking example (un exemple frappant), a double-edged
sword (une epee a double trenchant),diametrically opposed (diamétralement
oppose), not to mince words (ne pas macher ses mots), cornerstone (pierre angulaire),
with the naked eye (a l'oeil nu), common denominator (denominateur commun),
lion's share (part du lion), to hand a blank check (donner un cheque en blanc),
to kill two birds with one stone (une pierre, deux coups), to cast the first
stone (jeter la premiere pierre), to rest upon one's laurels (dormir sur ses
lauriers), a burning question (une question brulante), to thank from the bottom
of one's heart (remercier du fond de son coeur), to have goose bumps (avoir
la chair de poule), skirt chaser (coureur de jupon), to strike the iron while
it's hot (frapper le fer quand il est chaud), vicious circle (un cercle vicieux),
read between the lines (lire entre les lignes), a ticking time bomb (une bombe
a retardement), a matter of life and death (une question de vie ou de mort),
spring up like mushrooms (pousser comme des champignons), a ray/glimmer of hope
(un rayon d'espoir), paper tiger (tigre en papier), witch hunt (chasse aux sorcieres,
brain drain (fuite de cerveau), from the bottom of the heart (du fond du Coeur),
the cream of the cream (la crème de la crème), safety valves (les
valves de sauvetage), to rule with an iron fist (diriger avec un bras de fer),
to run the risk of (courir le risqué), a lone ranger (cavalier seul),
to have a soft spot (avoir un point faible), evil incarnate (le diable incarne),
the law of the jungle (la loi de la jungle), to swim against the current (nager
a contre-courant), to shoot oneself in the foot (se tirer une balle dans le
pied), a rallying cry (un cri de ralliement), to come empty-handed (rentrer
les mains vides), a lion's share (la part du lion), to be diametrically opposed
(être diamétralement oppose), goatie (barbuche de chèvre),
pepper and salt hair (cheveux poivre et sel), to be armed to the teeth (être
armé jusqu'aux dents), sticking points (points saillants), honeymoon
(lune de miel), to settle the matter once and for all (résoudre la question
une fois pour toutes), être plus catholique que le pape (to be more catholic
than the Pope), to cry wolf (crier au loup,) to be behind bars (être derrière
les verrous), a thorny question (une question épineuse), to be on the
same wavelength (être sur la même longueur d'onde), pell-mell (pêle-mêle),
to roll one's sleeves (retrousser les manches), to read between the lines (lire
entre les lignes), to have one's feet on the ground (avoir les pieds sur terre),
to get goosebumps (avoir la chair de poule 'to have chicken's flesh'), to get
the last laugh (rira bien qui rira le dernier), if the mountain doesn't go to
Mohamed, Mohamed goes to the mountain (si la montagne ne va pas à Mohamed,
Mohamed va à la montagne), lightening visit (une visite éclaire,
crocodile tears (les larmes de crocodile), to get goose bumps (avoir la chair
de poule), to munch one's words (mâcher ses mots), it's not the end of
the world (ce n'est pas la fin du monde), a ghost town (une ville fantôme).,
with the naked eye (à l'oeil nu), between the hammer and the anvil (entre
le marteau et l'enclume), the cradle of civilization ( le berceau de civilization),
to ring alarm bells ( tirer la sonnette d'alarme), free fall (chute libre),
belt tightening (serrer la ceinture), inferiority/superiority complex, the ends
justify the means (les fins justifient les moyens)., to roll up sleeves (retrousser
les manches), to swim against the stream/current (nager contre le courrent),
to draw the conclusion (tirer la conclusion), behind bars (derrière les
verroux), cold blood (sang froid), minutely detailed (minutieusement détaillé,
from the four corners of the world (des quatre coins du monde), to point the
finger (pointer le doigt), visceral hatred (une haine viscérale), everybody
knows that X wears the pants in the house (tout le monde sait que c'est X qui
porte le pentalon à la maison), to draw attention (attirer l'attention),
to draw a conclusion (tirer la conclusion), to put on a pedestal (mettre sur
le pedestral), it is written black on white (c'est écrit noir sur blanc),
an iron fist in a velvet glove (un bras de fer dans un gant de soie), at the
helm of the ship of the state (au gouvernail du bateau de l'état), to
hear it from that ear (l'entendre de cette oreille)., not to believe one's eyes
(ne pas en croire ses oreilles), to throw the towel (jeter l'éponge).,
a burning desire (un désir brûlant), brain washing (lavage de cerveau),
braindrain (fuite de cerveau), puppet government (un gouvernement de marionettes),
mushroom town (ville champignon), shantytown (bidonville).
There are some calques which have changed slightly by changing only one word:
loin des yeux loin du coeur (far from eyes far from heart>out of sight out
of mind), arme à double trenchant (a double-edged weapon>double edged
sword), to pay attention prêter attention (lend attention>pay attention),
dormir sur ses lauriers (to sleep on one's laurels>to rest on one's laurels)
Mythology, Greco-Roman history, the bible and literature
Trojan horse, holy grail, between Scylla and Charybdis, Procrustean bed, the
sword of Damocles, to cross the Styx, to fiddle while Rome burns, to cross the
Rubicon, Orwellian twist, quixotic adventure, Gargantuan appetite, catch-22,
Herculean task, Sisyphean task, Delphic answers/comments, to kill the goose
that lays golden eggs, Pyrrhic war, forbidden fruit, to cast the first stone,
to wash one´s hands, to turn the other cheek, a sacrificial lamb, to sell
one's soul to the devil, to cross the Rubicn, to cast the first stone, to turn
the other cheek., to kill the goose that laid the golden eggs, the fountain
of youth, the tree of knowledge, David and Goliath, to unleash demons, to rise
like a phoenix from the ashes, to sacrifice X on the altar of Y, a needle in
a haysack, good Samarithan
Journalist lingo:
X could not be reached for comment, a high government official who spoke on
condition of anonymity, to invoke the Fifth Amendment, talking points, pundit,
pork barrel, bull market, bear market, on both sides of the aisles (Republican
and Democratic Congress), on both sides of the Atlantic, gunboat diplomacy,
sunshine policy, to send the stock market tumbling, photo opportunity, a domino
effect, p-r,. to have a domino effect, exhibit A..
Euphemisms:
To embellish/stretch the truth, to color facts, friendly fire, collateral damage,
to make love, to downsize, comfort women, a four-letter word., fallen soldiers,
to exercize poor judgment
Synonymous clichés
The use of powerful metaphors is what renders certain linguistic expressions
cliches. Their "buzz-words", "catch phrases", and "sound
bites" characteristics and the fact that they can be used in different
contexts is what causes them to be overused. Clichés are thus not only
polysemous , being able to kil two birds with one stone, but synonymous as well.
It is the reason why there are many clichés which have the same meaning.
Consider the following:
To open a can of worms<>to stir up a hornet's nest<>to open a Pandora's
box<>to light a rocket's fuse; to show one's face<> to show one's
true colors; political spectrum<>political landscape; as the story unfolds<>
as the story starts to unravel; to go down the drain<>to go up in smoke,
skyrocketing prices<>to send prices to the stratosphere; to take a back
seat<>to put on the back burner, state of the art<>cutting edge
,root cause<>the straw that broke the camel's back, powder keg<>a
ticking time bomb, to turn a blind eye<>to look the other way<>to
turn a deaf ear<>to turn one's back, to stand tall <>to hold one's
head high, to boomerang<>to backfire<>to fall on one's sword, to
connect the dots<>to solve the jigsaw puzzle<>to put two and two
together, middle of the road <>mainstream, the nuts and bolts of<>
the ABC of <> the bread and butter of, to be hard-wired<> to be
pre-programmed, to be on the loose<>to be still at large, to be deep-rooted<>to
be entrenched<>to be ingrained, to have second thoughts<>to change
one's mind, watchdog<>watchful eye, the launching pad<>the starting
point<> the springboard<>the steppingstone<>a jumping off<>a
doormat, a done deal<> a foregone conclusion, to drop charges<>to
throw the case out, Achilles heel<>soft spot, hawks<>hardliners,
doves<>bleeding hearts, to go to great lengths<>to do one's best,
a hallmark<>a benchmark, X of all stripes<>all walks of life, one-dimensional
guy<>a low-life guy<>a Neanderthal, to be on the fast lane<>
roller coaster, to run out of steam<>to get burned out, to be sprinkled
with<>to be inundated with, to keep the spirits up<>to keep a high
morale, a mouthpiece<>a spokesperson., to pale next to<>to be overshadowed
by, to be a household name<>to be on people's radar screen, a cocktail<>a
hodgepodge<>a smorgasbord, ups and downs<>highs and lows<>peaks
and valleys, to be in the back seat<>to be on the back burner, to ebb
and flow<>to come and go, lifeblood<>backbone, entrenched<>embedded<>deep
rooted<>firmly implanted<>ingrained<>deep-seated, fat cats<>big
shots, the bread and butter of <> the nuts and bolts of, to root out<>to
weed out<>to drain the swamps, to give the green light<>to give
the carte blanche, landmark<>hallmark<>benchmark, trademark<>signature,
to be at standstill<>to be put on hold, to kill the goose that lays the
golden eggs<>to bite the hand that feeds you, to set the stage<>to
lay the groundwork, to miss the point<>not to get it, to connect the dots<>
to fit the pieces of the jigsaw puzzle, lightening rod<>magnet, a trailblazer<>a
pioneer<>a pathfinder, to spearhead<>to orchestrate, a bedrock<>a
stronghold, to be at large<>to be still on the run, to crop up <>to
spring up<> to mushroom<>to sprout, to carry X as badge of honor
<> to wear X on one's sleeve, to drop charges<> to throw the case
out, X at the embryonic stage<> X still in its infancy, watchdog<>whistle
blower, to lay to rest<>to pull the plug, , to burn to the ground<>to
go up in flames, a chain reaction<>a domino effect, to have a name recognition<>to
be a household name, to mastermind<>to spearhead, vanguard<>trailblazer<.>pathfinder<>pioneer,gold
standard<>yardstick<>benchmark, not to hold water (argument)<>to
be toothless, who in their right mind<>who on earth, to be history<>to
be a thing of the past, to bring X to their knees<>to bring X to heel,
to up the ante<>to bring to a grinding halt, to zero in on <>to
focus on, to dovetail<>to go along, to wrap up X<>to put final touches,
at the height of one's career<>at the pinnacle of one's career, to rise
exponentially<>to skyrocket<>to jump into the stratosphere, to catch
fire<>to be an instant phenomenon, a sitting duck<>an easy prey<>fair
game, the barometer<>the yardstick, to be nonplused<>not to be impressed,
trademark<>hallmark<>signature; bedrock<>cornerstone, derring-do<>daredevil,
Achille's heel<>soft spot, in X's embryonic stage<>in X's infancy,
to X around the clock<>to X 24/7, to jump ship<>to walk out of the
door, to paint X with broad brush strokes<>to cast with a large net, a
resounding victory<>a crushing victory, a walking encyclopedia<>
a Renaissance man, to walk on a tight rope<> to skate on thin ice, an
11th-hour X<> a last-minute X, between Scylla and Charybdis<>between
a rock and a hard place, bedrock<>cornerstone, hotbed <> breeding
ground, a tangled web<>an intricate network, to draw closer to <>to
inch closer to, to zero in on <> to hone in on, a dead heat<>a neck-to-neck
, an old beau<>an old flame, at the cutting edge<> at the forefront<>state
of the art, a far cry<>a stark constrast, here you are!<>there you
go!, to receive a standing ovation<>to bring X to its feet, to push the
envelope<>to go overboard, fast track<>roller coaster, to eat crow<>to
X tail between one's legs, slam dunk<>a piece of cake, to catch somebody
with his pants down<>to catch somebody with his hands in something,to
tie the knot<>to march down the aisle, to break the logjam<>to break
the deadlock, to be a fair game<>to be an easy prey, to put on the finishing
touches<>to smooth the rough edges of<>to wrap up,to be caugth red-handed<>to
be caught with the pants down , a virtuoso performance<>a tour de force,
to be tucked between X and Y<>to be sandwiched between X and Y, to be
in cahoots with<>to kowtow, to follow suit<>to jump on the bandwagon
, as the story opens<>as the story unfolds, Achilles' heel<>soft
spot, there is no there there<>where is the beef?, low key<>low
profile, a tempest in a tea pot<>to make fuss over a triffle, to wake
up and smell the coffee<>to face the music, standard-bearer<>flagship<>crown
jewel, to go down the drain<>to go down the tubes<>to go up in flames<>to
go up in smoke, to dig one's grave<>to bite the dust<>to meet one's
Maker(end)<>to kick the bucket, a con artist<>a snake-oil salesman,
old habits diehard<>you can't teach an old dog new tricks, to close the
chapter on X <>to turn the page on X, to open a new chapter<>to
open a new page
Since the majority of clichés are metaphors, synonymy is possible because
the same referent can be expressed by different types of metaphors, visual by
aural, smell by touch, etc.
Source Domain of Cliches
The source domain of clichés, is the same as that of metaphors: words
which refer to the human body, human activities and space. A great number of
metaphors come from words associated with the five senses, namely sight, sound,
smell, touch, taste. Abstract concepts, for instance are described by giving
them form, shape, size, and color. They may be described in terms of sound also
with words which refer to pitch, noise, loudness, frequency, and harmony. They
might be also conceptualized using terms of touch with words which refer to
temperature (such as hot, warm, cool, cold, ice, freeze)) and tactile reflex
(such rough, soft, sharp, dull) or weight (heavy, light). Taste also provides
many metaphors and clichés especially with the following words: juicy,
delicious, sweet, sour ,saucy, bitter, seasoned, to pepper. Feelings such as
happiness, sadness, joy, anger or personality are also attributed to abstract,
inanimate or non-human beings. Human activities such as moving, eating, farming,
hunting, fishing, building, sports are a fertile land for clichés. Space
as a location (open space, closed, bounded, unbounded and discontinuous), container,
conduit and destination, is a super metaphor used in many clichés. Anthropocentrism
and anthropomorphism are not limited to language but used in all semiotic systems
as well.
Using concepts to express other concepts by the unconscious mind is referred
to as conceptual metaphors (Lakoff 1980, 1999).
The "journey metaphor" and "seeing as knowing" metaphor
are given for illustration purposes.
Journey metaphors:
In many languages of the world, the journey metaphor is used to refer to people's
activities: education, career, politics, business, marriage, conversation, etc.
The beginning of the activity is seen as the point of departure and the goal
as the destination. The obstacles are considered as roadblocks or stumbling
blocks. The success of activities is facilitated by good road conditions and
so on. Take for example the expressions glass ceiling and glass wall which are
used in ethnic studies to refer to the lack of both social vertical and horizontal
mobility. Below more examples are provided.
To get off the ground, step by step, along the way, down the road, around the
corner, under way, to cross paths, to pave the way, to clear the way, to walk
one's way up, to go out one's way, to go into one's own way, road blocks, stumbling
blocks, stepping stone, to go an extra mile, an uphill battle, to follow in
the footsteps, a step in the right direction, uncharted territory, a leap into
the unknown, to go hand in hand, to give a green light, to go to great lengths,
to be a step ahead, to go so far, to go as far as, to go hand in hand, to go
along with, breakthrough, to go to the extreme, to come to power, to come home
to roost, to come a long way, to put a foot in the door, to stand in somebody's
way, deadlock, breakthrough, to be a turning point, to be on empty, one-way
street, dead end, to be in the driver's seat, to be in the back seat, to grind
to a halt, to shift gears, to move into the higher gear, to push into the overdrive,
to stonewall, to make a sharp right turn, a one-way street, to find one's way,
.
Seeing as knowing metaphor
Knowledge is acquired through good vision and ignorance is caused by lack of
it such as blindness, myopia or darkness.
To see a light a the end of the tunnel, to eye open, to take a fresh look,
a rising star, to look facts in the face, to be high on the agenda, an outstanding
figure, to keep a low profile, to shed light, point of view ,to be shrouded
in secrecy, dark Africa, dim and distant past, dark ages, to enter into the
picture, to come into focus, visible to the naked eye, to turn a blind eye,
to put into perspective, to blur the lines, to see no farther than one's nose,
put up a smoke screen, to sweep under the rug, to cast a shadow, to be in total
darkness ,to come to the surface, to be shortsighted, to see far, to have a
narrow/broad view, to be on the radar screen .
Clichés and metaphors are universal and found in all languages. The
only difference is their hierarchization, maximization and minimization of these
senses in specific languages which largely depend on environmental factors,
history and existential experiences. The majority of English cliches and metaphors
use images probably to due the fact is a huge country with vast plains. Others
are borrowed because of the colonial history. Other languages might maximize
other senses such as sound, smell, touch because of respective environment and
existential experiences.
Declichétization
Obviously the majority of words and expressions enter the language as clichés.
They cease to be clichés when they reach the symbolic level when the
transparency of the linguistic motivation is lost. The majority of linguistic
signs in their genesis are iconic but later become opaque. For instance very
few English speakers know that the word pen like the French word 'plume' meant
'feather'. Feathers were the ones which were used to write when writing was
invented.
Because of their high frequency in usage some complex noun phrases have now
become like single words in native speakers' minds as evidenced by the writing
system in American English.:
milestone, touchstone, keystone, capstone, trademark, hallmark, landmark, benchmark,
oddball, hardball, screwball, deadlock, breakthrough, egghead, mastermind, brainchild,
lifeblood, springboard, etc.
This lexicalization of clichés, treating compound words as single words
has created a reanalysis, treating one part of the word as either a suffix or
prefix.
Landscape which is one of the favorite as seen in such expressions as
political landscape, legal landscape, social landscape, intellectual landscape,
emotional landscape, mental landscape,
has created new words such as
skyscape, dreamscape, cityscape, townscape, streetscape, moonscape, mudscape,
rockscape, oceanscape, seascape, icescape, snowscope, gridscape., woodscape,
footscape, cloudscape, soundscape, summerscape, studioscape, beachscape, worldscape,
urbanscape, riverscape.
thus treating scape as a suffix.
The adjective deep is being affixed to different types of words to express metaphorically
how important or superficial things or events are:
skin-deep, knee-deep, bone-deep
As Guy Deutscher (2005) observed, clichés are "a necessary stage
between new imagery and everyday vocabulary". A lot of vocabulary and linguistic
expressions enter the language as clichés but they fade through overexposure
and overuse.
Clichés are the linguistic expressions which still keep their freshness,
newness and vivacity. Interestingly, etymology which studies the origin of lexical
items and expressions, seems to attract no interest from historical linguistics
which puts more emphasis on sound change, sound correspondance and syntactic
change, ignoring the history of words. This neglect is due to the fact that
modern theoretical linguistics has never been interersed in the meaning and
function of language and also to the methodology since all sciences study systems
and not individual items which constitute the system. All sciences start from
top down before they can go from the botton up to understand the form and the
function that each item plays in the system as a whole.
IV. Why linguists have neglected metaphors.
In post-structuralist linguistics, however, led by Noam Chomsky, metaphors
have been ignored by linguists because of the peripheral role that semantics
plays and also because metaphors are considered to be linguistic signs "thus
arbitrary" and therefore of no interest to linguistic theory.
Generative linguistics is still Saussurian in character. The reason why metaphors
have been ignored by linguists is that they are part of the vocabulary thus
linguistic signs. Signs, according to Ferdinand de Saussure are arbitrary thus
not interesting for scientific linguistic inquiry. The study of the genesis
and dynamism of signs and structures, shows, however, that they all start as
icons and that it is through overexposure and overuse that the iconicity and
the motivation between forms and their meanings get lost.
When Generative Grammar was born, its motto was "semantics free syntax"
or "autonomous syntax" with its famous illustrative sentence "Colorless
green ideas sleep furiously". Although new theories were born such as Case
Grammar, Generative Semantics, Lexical-Functional Grammar, Relational Grammar,
to name just a few, to show the importance of meanings and function in syntax,
formal generative grammars still dominates in linguistics. The criticisms have
strengthened the theory because Chomsky and his followers incorporated these
suggestions in the later forms of the theory , thus improving it. All languages
that have been studied so far support Chomsky's ideas of Universal Grammar and
the innateness hypothesis, namely that all languages share the same grammar
and differ only on the surface and that language is part of human endowment.
That langugage is innate is evidenced by the fact that children from any llinguistic
background acquire language competence at a very early age without any stimulus
thus contracicting behavioralists led by the late Harvard psychologist E.B.Skinner.
For instance, tone representation, assignment and rules are out of control of
the conscious mind and tone languages' native speakers are literally tone deaf
thus unable to teach tone rules to their children, but children don't have any
problems using these tones perfectly. This is evidence that indeed the grammar
of language is a faculty of the mind where it has its own software.
Syntax influence in today's linguistics is also evidenced by the number of dissertations,
the job openings, the kind of articles published in first-tier leading linguistic
journals,linguistic departments' curruculums, etc. The triumph of formalism
over functionalism was due to its advances and contributions in both descriptive
and theoretical linguistics with mathematically elegantly formulated rules in
syntax, phonology and morphology. Looking at the form rather than meanings and
functions was also more attractive and easier because when dealing with exotic
languages, the linguist with his or her tape recorder enregisters the native
speaker and comes back to the office or laboratory and starts analyzing the
data and formulates the rules which are responsible for the sound system (phonology),
the word formation (morphology) and the sentence structure (syntax). There are
only four types of sentence structure (SVO, SOV, VSO, OVS), four types of syntactic
rules: permutations, substitutions, deletions and additions. There is a limited
number of sounds. Only five types of phonological rules: assimilations, dissimilations,
neutralizations, deletions and additions
Mastering the semantics of new languages takes a long time because meanings
are intimately connected to culture.
Thus despite the pioneering work on metaphors by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson
(1980), mainstream linguistics is more involved in syntax, morphology and phonology
and semantics is still on the back burner. I myself became involved in metaphors
not as a linguist but as a semiotician interested in finding out the relationship
between the sign and its referent not only in language but in all semiotic systems
mostly symbols and rituals.
Frustrated linguists such as George Lakoff, Giles Fauconnier,Leonald Talmy,
Dan Slobin, Ronald Langacker, Bill Croft,
gathered to create a subfield
of linguistics that they have called cognitive linguistics. Although its inquiry
includes syntax, morphology and phonology, it focuses more on semantics. They
forget, however, that generative grammar is also cognitive, since its goal is
to find out how language is represented in the native speaker's mind. Noam Chomsky
in Syntactic Structures recognized that linguistics is a subfield of phychology.
These linguists are right, however, in pushing linguists to put semantics at
the center stage because of the role it plays in cognition. Syntactic structures
are just containers of linguistic expressions. Rules which make up these structures
are very simple and very minimal which means that the mind spends more time
on deciphering and decoding the content. As the study of clichés and
metaphors has shown concepts in the mind are represented as visual images, sounds,
smells, tastes, or touches, any linguistic theory interested in how language
is represented in the mind which ignores them is obviously mistaken.
Since the goal of linguistics is to understand how language is represented in
the mind, it has to look at all aspects of language, not only at computational
rules but at the contents of the building blocks of these structures.
Another important reason why there is little interest in semantics from linguists
is due to the fact that the leading semanticists all have a background in formal
semantics which is more philosophical than linguistic. Philosophers of language
such as Bertrand Russell, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Richard Montague, William Van
Orman Quine and their students are more interested in how structures of natural
languages express universal truth, knowledge and belief whereas linguists are
interested in language use. Linguists as scientists rely on empirical evidence
whereas philosophers as thinkers are interested in ideas which many times are
not testable.
The lexicalist and the transformationalist hypothesis
In the early beginning of generative grammar there was a dispute between the
"transformationalist hypothesis" and the "lexicalist hypothesis".
Lexicalists were convinced that some grammatical, phonological and morphological
information have to be included in the dictionary to reflect how the mind functions,
whereas transformationalists believed that lexical information was not needed
in the grammar. In other words, both believed that there are two independent
locations in the brain one for grammar and one for vocabulary but differed on
how much each software should borrow from each other.
The study of clichés has shown that indeed the dictionary carries a heavy
burden because not only do complex structures but fully formed complete sentences
as well appear "non transformally generated", in the dictionary. This
creates a serious problem for generative grammar which claims that native speakers
are supposed to never imitate but always use their innately language endowment
using grammatical rules and the vocabulary to create their own novel grammatical
structures. Putting theoretical issues aside, in more practical terms, since
these clichés are other people's linguistic expressions, which part of
the linguiistic compotent they belong to? Grammar or vocabulary? The answer
is obvious. A good dictionnary has to include them, the way it does for idiomatic
expressions.
The cliché paradox
Before discussing the cliché paradox let's face look at the following
eight paradoxes: the Rwanda paradox, the oil curse, the paradox of the contented
female worker, the Hispanic paradox, the progress paradox , the twin paradox,
the Zeno's paradox and the Inca paradox
The oil curse also referred to as the "paradox of plenty" is used
to refer to developing countries which are very rich in natural resources. They
become prey to giant predators namely multinationals and industrialized nations
and this causes a lot of suffering to the general population because they spread
their tentacles interfering in internal politics, creating political instability
and installing corrupt leaders who will insure the predators' interest. Conflicts
in countries such as DRC, Angola, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Nigeria and Sudan in
Africa have resulted from their oil, natural gas, and gold and diamonds and
Bolivia and Venezuela in Latin America face similar problems because of their
oil and natural gas . Iraq would not be in the deplorable situation it is in
right now, if it were not the second oil producer in the world.
The Rwanda paradox refers to the treatment of criminals in the 1994 Tutsi genocide
in Rwanda. The masterminds of genocide are in Arusha living in hotel-like prisons
and will never face death penalty, whereas the majority of executioners are
in Rwanda jails and might be executed for their heinous crimes.
The "paradox of the contented female worker" was used by the New York
Times columnist John Tierney . Apparently social scientists have found out that
women in the work place don't like to go into cut-throat jobs which require
them to compete and sacrifice their families and health such as the Wall Street.
Social scientists have also found that Hispanics, eventhough they have less
education and income than Anglos, seem to live better lives, with less physical
and psychological problems than Anglos: hence the coining of the Hispanic paradox.
The Progress Paradox is the title of a book by Gregg Easterbrook. The subtitle
is "How life gets better while people get worse". He points out that
the symptoms of the progress paradox are "choice anxiety", "abundance
denial", "collapse anxiety", "the revolution of satisfied
expectations".
The "twin paradox" is used in physics and has to do with Einstein's
relativity thesis. It deals with time travel. According to this relativity theory
it is theoretically possible to travel back in the past and witness or prevent
events which took place or travel to the future and see events which have not
taken placed yet. In this scheme of things if a twin is sent in this journey
into the future, he or she can come back younger and on the return find his
or her twin already dead.
The Zeno's Paradox is about what the Greek philosopher claims is the illusion
of motion in an infinitely divisible space and time. It includes four paradoxes:
the Dichotomy paradox, the Achilles and the Tortoise paradox, the Arrow paradox
and the Stadium paradox.
The Inca paradox has to do with the lack of evidence that the Inca empire invented
a writing system. Recorded histories show that empires because of their size
and complex administration have a writing system. Scientists are wondering if
Quipus, "mysterious bundles of colored and knotted threads which served
as the Inca's means of recording information" were used to represent numbers
or if these knots were not personal mnemonic devices but a true writing system
which was used to record and transmit information.
The toxicity of clichés
Clichés are indeed "prepackaged ideas" because the users believe
in what they mean. Which unfortunately happen to be sometimes deeply flawed
concepts and deceitful myths. Consider: Dark Africa, melting pot, the wild west,
the Deep South, middle class, ivory tower, white-collar crime, culture of poverty,
model minority, globalization. Dark Africa, which uses a vision metaphor, entails
a continent that nobody knows about and which in turn has not seen light yet.
This cliché echoes Joseph Conrad's views expressed in his book In the
Heart of Darkness. The melting pot metaphor and cliché which has already
been debunked also implies that America is the blending of all cultures when
indeed the minorities were forced to abandon their cultures and to assimilate
to the majority culture. The wild west explains and justifies also the behavior
of whites towards Indians in the Far West when they killed them like animals
without any remorse or retaliation and retribution by the government which instead
offered bounties for the heads of Native Americans especially in California
during the Gold Rush, the Transcontinental Railroad construction during the
expansionist ideology of Manifest Destiny which believed that the US had a divine
right to expand from the rising sea to the shining sea. The cliché implies
total lawlessness, a rule of the jungle with nobody in control which is a myth
since the US government was in total control. The term Deep South which refers
to the Southeast states including those which border the Gulf Mexico connotes
for some speakers a racist and backward region which has been unable to keep
pace with the rest of nation. The term middle class is a fuzzy concept because
a $20,000 employee and a $200,000 cannot have the same values and lifestyles.
The expression ivory tower is used to refer to university professors with a
negative connotation because confined within the halls of the academe they are
apparently disconnected from the outside world reality. This is why the term
academic has also acquired a negative meaning, implying something which lacks
seriousness, substance and depth in such expressions as that is just academic.
This is where also the cliché, absent-minded professor comes from. Academics,
however, as history shows, are the main agents and catalysts of social change
not only because of their ideas and activism but also because they are the primary
targets of any political system which wants to maintain itself in power. Unfortunately,
because of this cliché, there are some universities and some faculty
members who don't join or support unions because they believe that unions are
only for blue-collar workers forgeting that they are also employees who have
to negotiate their salaries, benefits and better working conditions. A high
executive who commits a white-collar crime siphoning millions of dollars from
a corporation, forcing it to file bankruptcy and fire its employees in thousands,
sometimes receives a lesser court sentence than a petty criminal who is caught
smoking dope or shoplifting. Some sociologists explain low class lifestyles
and values such as spending without saving, having problems in future planning
as culture of poverty. This is a myth, however, because there are many people
in this society who were able to get out of this situation and were able to
move both vertically, climbing the social ladder, and horizontally, being accepted
in the whole national landscape. People raised on the mean streets are not all
going to run into trouble with the law victims of envornmental determinism.
. The model minority label is used by social scientists and the media and the
politicians to refer to Asian-Americans is a myth also. This cliché which
unfortunately a very large segment of the society believes, claims that this
particular group is different from other minority groups namely Native Americans,
Mexican Americans and African Americans because they share the same values as
the majority namely work ethic and the desire to succeed. This cliché
is detrimental to Asian Americans. First it lumps all Asian-Americans together
as a homogenized group as if they had the same nationality, culture, the same
motive for migration and the same existential experiences and the same economical
status. And since this cliché is in a sense a praise and some kind of
acceptance from the majority, Asians were forced to project this image for a
long time, suffering in silence, refusing to seek help from the police to fight
Asians-on-Asians crimes in their communities. People romanticize and exoticize
Chinatowns forgetting that they are ghettos. This cliché prevented Asian-Americans
also from fighting for their basic constitutional, civil and human rights when
they were violated, thus allowing the self-fulfilling prophecy as far as respect
of the oppressive institution is concerned but without necessarily achieving
full citizen rights status. The cliché root causes is used by the media
and some social scientists to explain different types of conflicts found in
many pluralistic societies such as civil wars, mass massacres and genocides.
This cliché has been debunked and should be replaced instead by seeds
of hatred or breeding ground.
Globalization is both a slogan and a cliché in today's business. The
concept is being pushed as the best thing for the world economy. This entails
free trade, privatization of state companies, etc. This approach is good of
course for corporate America and other Western big corporations which definitely
are going to monopolize this global market since in this dog-eat-dog world the
developing countries' companies will not be able to compete with the giants
of industrialized nations. Which will result in what anti-globalization activists
call the "MacDonaldization " or "Hollywoodization" of the
world. One good example that globalization is one-way trade is the subsidization
of farmers in Western nations by their governments which prevents farmers from
developing countries from selling their products on the international competitive
market. Countries such as Burkina Faso, Mali and Niger, can't sell their cotton
which is the only cash crop they produce because of the subsention of cotton
farmers by the US government making the price more attractive because it is
cheaper.
The cliché paradox: a window to the mind
Like proberbs, clichés which they too, use mnemoric devices, namely
rhythm, rhyme, repetition and metaphors, they validate preconceived ideas.
Clichés are a useful and necessary tool for the mind They play a crucial
role in cultural preservation, nation building and collective identity. The
use of clichés implies acceptance and approprition of somebody else's
words and ideas.
Clichés are guardians of collective memory . Memory plays a very big
role in biological evolution and for human survival. For the human species to
survive, we have to remember everything that is important to the society such
as names, important dates, time, seasons, animals, plants, etc. Eventhough in
literate industrialized societies, there are many other devices which are used
to keep the memory such as books, museums, computers and so on, people still
rely heavily on oral tradition or vertical transmission of knowledge as opposed
to the horizontal which implies an interactional discourse and discussion. The
brain unconsciously draws heavily on past experiences. It is the reason why,
for instance, in this computer age, pre-industrial age metaphors such as as
trailblazer, to spearhead, rule of thumb, as the crow flies, a stone's throw,
to kill two birds with one stone, till the cows come home, to save/plan for
rainy days, to go in search of green pastures, a fair-weather friend, to work
one's fingers to the bone, to burn the midnight oil are still alive today. In
most of the world's languages, the metaphors to fall into a trap, preys and
predators are used to remind us that all modern societies were once hunter-gathers.
For maximum efficiency, the number of linguistic signs which refer to the infinite
real world is reduced. For those who are familiar with the Chinese writing system
which uses more than 5,000 symbols know, Chinese linguists are struggling to
simplify and reduce this number because it is not functional. First, it is becoming
difficult for even specialists to remember all of them and second, it becomes
ever harder to remember their respective meanings.
Japanese uses four writing systems: kanji (borrowed from Chinese), hirakana
(foreign words), katakana and romanu. The Roman writing system is becoming more
popular because like English, it only uses 26 symbols or letters.
The minimization of signs in language is not limited to language but to other
semiotic systems as well such as symbols and rituals. This tendency to reduce
the number naturally results in the polyfunctional use of signs, symbols and
rituals which creates polysemy: texts with multiple meanings.
All efficient systems use a principle of economy: a minimum use of paradigms
and syntagms for a maximum performance, or to use a computer metaphor less input
but more output, which is again a paradox.
The metaphoric cliché is multifunctional and can be used in different
contexts. We saw many cases already in the section which discusses synyonymous
clichés.
For instance the cliché to out-X X where X stands for any linguistic
expression which means to out-do or out-perform something or somebody in what
they are supposed to excell is used in zillion expressions to refer to different
situations
such as to out-Google google in internet search, to out-Bush Bush in concocting
stories of the production of weapons of mass desruction, to out-Hilter Hilter
in evilness and in mass killings, to out-France France in producing better wines,etc.
Contrary of Raimo Anttila's claim that there is a tendency in natural languages
to be isomorphic what he calls "one meaning one form", asymmetry between
words and their respective referents is more natural than symmetry which implies
a one-to-one relationship) between the referent and the linguistic sign. The
symmetry would require more space storage, more work on memory and material
retrieval. Finite means are used to refer to infinite experiences. The language
uses few sounds, few morphemes, few syntactic rules and few words. This is not
unique to language but a characteristic of all semiotic systems
Cognition
Clichés as metaphors help us in understandig novel experiences and complex
concepts and in memory preservation.
As it was pointed out earlier, the majority of linguistic signs enter the language
as icons or clichés. Because of time the transparency becomes lost and
the relationship between the referent and the sign which refers to it becomes
part of the unconscious mind. Not only are the jargon in professions and academic
fields metaphors but are also the majority of everyday expressions that we use
are metaphors that the conscious mind is not aware of.
Many people use expessions such as beautiful song, big problem, hard question,
sad story
without being aware that they are using metaphors. Songs are
sounds but a visual metaphor is used in the first example. A problem is an abstract
concept but a visual metaphor of size is used and question is also an abstract
concept but uses a qualifier tactile metaphor.The adjective sad modifying story
is not used literally but as metonymy. A metaphor entails similarity between
the literal meaning and the figurative meaning whereas a metonymy implies an
association between the referent in the primary plane and the one in the secondary
plane. The association in this case is that of cause and effect.
In linguistics, for instance, and this is true for other academic disciplines
as well, words that are used to describe linguistic data and phenomena are metaphors
as are terms for new theories. The latest theory, the Minimalist Program, is
a metaphor borrowed from art. Generative Grammar is metaphor as well. Deep structure
or underlying structure versus surface structure to describe the mental representation
versus the phonetic representation of sentences are obviously visual metaphors.
The terms trigger and target which are used to refer to linguistic elements
which are responsible for changes and the ones which are being affected are
gun metaphors. The metaphors launching sites and landing sites used to refer
to initial positions within the structure and the final position, respectively,
after transformationl rules or phonological have taken place, are flying metaphors.
Promotions, demotions, raising and lowering terms used to refer to syntactic
phenomena which either put linguistic elements in prominent positions or the
opposite and main clauses or subordinate clauses and head nouns, auxiliary verbs,
subordinate clauses are about social hierarchy.
The majority of metaphors used in linguistics come construction and plantation
as examples below show:
Constructions metaphors:
foundations of language, language structures, language design,, sentence construction.
Plantation metaphors.
semantic fields, tree diagram, verb root, verb stem, branch, tree pruning.
Recent research has shown that all sciences not only do they use metaphors
to describe and explain physical phenomena, but that they also show the metaphoric
nature of scientific thought.
For instance, the physicist Lisa Randall became aware of the scientific metaphors
in physics and their misleading interpretations only when she found out that
the two leading theories in physics namely field theory and string theory were
translated in French,respectively as théorie des champs and théorie
des cordes. She didn't think that the translation was a correct rendition of
the English metaphors.
The reason why we are able to use computers, it is because its technology uses
metaphoric expressions which are familiar and understandable to all of us. For
instance, all command expressions such as save, open, move, launch, copy, cut,
paste, move, download
are metaphors.
Using metaphors borrowed from familiar semantic fields and themes has made it
possible for average people to use it and to understand how it functions. Some
of these themes is to consider the computer as an office, to go to the computer
as a journey or movement, the type of movement on it as a traffic, the display
on the computer screen as a menu, tools as small animals, problems as diseases.
The computer conceived as an office is show by these metaphors: desktop, laptop,
file, folder, window, hardware, tools, to throw a file into the trash, recycling
bin .
To use the computer is to go on a journey: to run a program, to run fast, to
surf the internet, to visit home pages,web navigation, to browse websites, to
go to a website, to crawl.
The restaurant metaphor menu is used to show that users have the option to select
among the many options that are displayed on the computer screeen they want
to use.
Problems on the computer as diseasemetaphors are: virus, worm
Small animal metaphors are : mouse, snailmail, bug
post metaphors: mailbox, voicemail, email address,
traffic metaphors are: web traffic, information highway, high speed internet
The book metaphors are: webpage, bookmark, to browse the web
What is interesting also is that many computer metaphors have entered the language
as well. Computer metaphors are now used to refer to the different functions
of the mind. The brain is seen as the hardware and the mind as software.
We are preprogrammed, reprogrammed, or hard-wired for something. We put something
into our database, we have our harddrives filled up, we have a memory installed,
we parse sentences. The brain is supposed to have neural networks and brain
circuity.
There is ofcourse a big difference between the computer and the brain. Unlike
the computer, the brain doesn't have enough space to store all lexical items.
It can't retrieve the memory very easily like the computer, either, due to the
fact that the brain does not store memory in one place.
What is interesting is that these computer metaphors which come from existing
metaphors are now used as new metaphors to refer to the mind. This is a case
of metametaphors, metaphors used to refer to new referents using existing metaphors.
All new technologies use familiar metaphors but they , too, in return contribute
new metaphors to the language as shown by the train metaphors ( to lose the
steam, robber barons, a whistle blow, train wreck, to derail a process
), the car metaphors, the plane metaphors, the space metaphors (it's not rocket
science, you don't have to be a rocket scientist,
)
The power of the mind as the existence of clichés shows is not how much
it can store, remember or retrieve but how it is able to do more with less.
For maximum performance and efficiency, it uses few computational rules and
reduces the lexical storage by giving new meanings and functions to words that
already exist to express infinite novel experiences. This polysemy of course
is sometimes responsible for ambiguity. Minimalism then is not only restricted
to the formal properties of language but to linguistic signs and semantic structures
as well.
I end this lecture by by raising another important fundamental question that
philosophers and scientists have not answered yet. Current research in cognitive
science has shown that ideas are not disembodied as Plato and Descartes had
previously claimed. Descartes went even farther with his famous statement "cogito
ergo sum" (I think therefore I am) and this is referred to as Cartesian
dualism, the separation of mind and body. But language is biologically based
and our brain is hard-wired to it as Noam Chomsky and cognitive scientists from
diverse disciplines have shown. Since we understand concepts only through metaphors,
and since science and philosophy are interconnected with culture and also use
metaphors to talk about scientific issues and that these metaphors can be misleading
as many scientists have pointed out especially with metaphors dealing with environment
and ecological systems and all academic disciplines go through paradigm shifts
almost every decade, can we talk about "objective reality" or "scientific
truth"?
References
Angler, Natalie. 2005. "Almost we spoke, we swore". New York Times
.
September 20, 2005.
Browne, Theodore. L. Making Truth: Metaphor in Science.
Crowft, W and D.A. Cruse. 2004. Cognitive Linguistics. Cambridge University
Press.
Deutscher, Guy. 2005. "Standing on the shoulders of clichés".
New York Times.
June 18, 2005.
Easterbrook, Gregg. 2005. The Progress Paradox.
Longman Dictionary of English Idioms. 1979. Longman
Urdang, Laurence@Nancy Laroche, eds. Picturesque Expressions: A Thematic
Dictionary. 1980. Detroit, Michigan: Gale Research Company
Kimenyi, Alexandre. "Iconicity of Binomial Expressions in English".
Kimenyi, Alexandre. "Cow Metaphors in Kinyarwanda"
Kimenyi, Alexandre. "The journey metaphor in Kinyarwanda".
Lakoff, G&M.Johnson. 1980. Metaphors we live by. Chicago University Press.
Partridge, Eric. 1980. A Dictionary of Cliches, 5th Edition. London&Boston,
Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Randall, Lisa. 2005. "Dangling particles", New York Times OP-ED September
18, 2005.
Rosenthal, Jack. 2005. "Mnemonics: In this information age, why remember
anything?" The New Times Magazine July 17, 2005 pp.16
Taylor, J.R. 2002. Cognitive Grammar. Oxford Univeristy Press.
Tierney, John. 2005. "What women want". New York Times.
(loaded to web 10/5/05)
|