|
The Body as Human Experience Metaphor
Alexandre Kimenyi
Body metaphors are found in all languages. They are used as dead metaphors
to refer to objects which have either physical or functional similarity to the
human body part or to the state of the body in general. A large number of idiomatic
expressions also use words which refer to the human body as either metaphors
or metonymies. Although the interest and academic inquiry in metaphors is the
object of many disciplines such as philosophy, pyschology, linguistics, anthropology,
artificial inelligence, literary criticism, etc. , there has been no attempt
to study this phenomenon systematically or to explain why they are used. This
chapter is devoted only to conceptual metaphors, metaphors that native speakers
use unconsciously thinking that they are using words which belong to the primary
plane of expression, to use Roland Barthes' terminology. The reason why metaphors
are used it is because of the asymmetry which exists between the finite number
of language vocabulary and the infinite nature of the world that these words
refer to. The finite nature of vocabulary is due to the size of the brain which
doesn't have enough space to store the lexical items and also to the limited
capacity of the memory which cannot retrieve all the information whenever it
is needed. The other reason these metaphors exist, it is because they help the
mind understand new experiences. This thus explains why body metaphors are universal.
The body is an inalienable possession and experiences in the world from the
cradle to the grave start with it.
I. The body condition metaphor
The physical and mental state of the body is used to relate to human experiences.
Positive experiences are referred to by linguistic expressions which denote
the well being of the body such as good health, vitality, energy,
and
bad experiences by words or expressions which designate or describe the bad
state of the body such its deterioration, sickness, weakness, etc.
This is illustated by examples below.
a healthy discussion, a valid (healthy) argument, an invalid (crippled) solution,
a dead relationship, a muscular mandate, a political headache, a spoiled child,
an ill-conceived idea, moral decay, a bruised ego, a bruising experience, a
rotten politician, a handicapped democracy, a defunc t system, a happy ending,
a joyous occasion, a sad story, to heal the wounds, to open old wounds, self-nflicted
wounds, the wounds of the past have remained raw, financial bleeding, to take
a deep breath, the society is still bearing the scars of its troubled past,
to lose one's mind, to be out of one's mind, to be brainwashed, a bureaucracy
in its dying throes, a sick joke, a sore need, a fractured childhood,
This state body metaphor is very much used to describe the state of the economy,
which is seen as either being in good health or sick, thus needing medical treatment.
the recovery of the economy, the ailing economy, to put a shot in the arm,
to inject a heavy dose in the economy, strong economy, a healthy economy, a
robust/strong economy, sluggish economy, to cripple the economy, a debilitating/deteriorating
economy, a paralyzed economy, lethargic economy, a moribund economy, to revive
the economy, to jump-start a sagging economy, the economy is in good shape,
lifeless economy, to cure the economy's ills, to harm/hurt the economy, the
economy is bleeding, a hemorrhaging economy, a hemorrhaging state budget, tourissm
is the lifeblood of the country's economy, a carcass of the economy, to revitalize/energize
the economy, the economy is suffering, the economy is back on its feet, tax
cuts would nurse the economy back to robust health, to try all sorts of remedies
to improve the economy's health, to pull the country out of an economic slump,
the economy is getting back on its feet, to feel theeconomy's pulse .
Personification or anthropocentric metaphors are known in poetry, literature
and literary criticism only as dead metaphors but it has escaped many scientists
that they are mostly used as conceptual metaphors.
II. Touching Metaphors
Touching metaphors refer to body contact or lack of it, taction, temperature
and weight. Events, actions or objects which are far from the body cannot have
impact on it. It is also impossible to understand them while they are far away.
It is only when there is direct contact with the body that they can have impact
and be understood.
1. Body Contact
Body contact metaphors show impact or understanding. Here are some examples.
to seize power, to cling to power, to pin one's hopes on something, to be able
to grasp complex concepts, the concept is beyong/out of reach, she didn't get
what he meant, to capture the meaning of an expression, to catch /grab somebody's
attention, it didn't occur to them that he was just joking, it escaped me that
the meeting was scheduled for today, a touching moment, to distance oneself
from something, to be loosely connected, to be linked events, to be tied to
organized crimes, Liberia's historic ties to the US, close friends, distant
relatives, to stay in contact, to be/stay in touch, to cross X's mind, to cut
ties, to sidestep the question, to come to grips with, to be captivated by a
theory, to seize an idea, the book touches on many subjects, a tangible result,
a striking example, his argument is supported by facts, she has been able to
retain her reputation, they still sustain that assertion, I will keep that in
mind, to take something seriously/lightly, to cross somebody's mind, the theory
still holds, the news of his son's death hit him pretty hard, hard-hitting images,
to be thunderstruck by the news, to hurt somebody's feelings, to inflict a damage
on somebody's reputation.
.
It is revealing to see that the meanings of verbs such as to understand and
comprehend, are still etymologically transparent and indeed conform and support
the notion that comprehension expressions come from body contact metaphors.
They come respectively from to stand under and the French verb 'comprendre'
to-with-take.
2. Temperature Metaphors
Temperature metaphors are used to describe a situation. The extreme heat and
the extreme cold connote uncomfortable situations whereas medium temperature
(warm) describes good situations.
to be/to put on the hot seat, to feel the heat, to put the heat on somebody,
a burning issue, in the heat of the civil rights' movement and the cold war,
to be in hot water, a heated discussion, a hotly contested report, a hot buttom,
to warm to an idea, a warm reunion/welcome, a warm book, a lukewarm reception,
to send chills down the spine, to to have a chilling effect, icy look, to give
a cold shoulder, to be cold-blooded, to kill in cold blood, frosty relationship,
to cool to the plan, to speak with cool frankness, demonstrations have cooled
down, with the cold eyes of a philosopher, the iciest days of the cold war,
to get cold feet, the cold logic of the law is warmed by a rich variety of experience,
a frigid reaction, the government officials have tried to turn down the flame
on hot story that the White House had helped ignite just days earlier.
The adjective hot sometimes has positive meaning, however, when it refers to
new things or phenomena as in fashion, ideas, products, which have taken the
center stage : a hot topic, a hot commodity
3. Weight Metaphors
Weight metaphors convey the importance, influence or the seriousness of things,
situations or events. The most important ones carry heavy weight and the least
important light weight.
the weight of words, to put a heavy emphasis on,a heavy accent, a political
heavy weight, a heavy drinker/fog, minuses outweigh pluses, to suffer heavy
losses, the heaviest attack, a heavily edited information, the concern is weighing
very heavily on the government officials, heavy traffic/smoking, to take things
lightly, to weigh options, to weigh heavily on, to rely heavily on try and true
methods, to detract attention from weightier matters, the similarities outweigh
the differences, to lift a ban/embargo, to throw one's weight around X, to use
the weight of the office, to pay a heavy price, to carry weight, the city still
bears the weight of its history, to crush under the weight of a dictatorial
regime, a heavy cross to bear, the President left the heavy lifting to the Legislature,
to be heavy-handed, to serve as counterbalance/counterweight, to carry a light/heavy
load of research, a heavy/lighter teaching load, to have a light impact, to
be relieved of a burden, to lighten a heavy discussion,to give a light prison
sentence, the recital ended on lighter note, to use a measured language, to
be balanced.
4. Taction Metaphors
The body sensations in contact with other objects such as 'soft', 'hard', are
used to refer to difficult or easy situations, strong or weak objects. Thus
'hard' and its synonyms refer to the former concept and 'soft' and its synonyms
to the latter.
a rough childhood/language/neighborhood, a hard situation/job/assignment, hardware,
hard sciences, solid research/argument, solid/hard evidence, his life has mellowed
with age, a mellow melody, a soft music, a soft-spoken individual, software,
a velvet nigth, a velvet revolution, a velvet y sound, a silky melody, a weak
response, a fragile personality, a smooth taste/talker, a smooth transition,
at tender age, the memory is suffused with magic which smoothes the rough edges
of the past.
Words which describe or refer to experiences which cause the most sensations
on the body act as conceptual metaphors for things which challenge the mind.
a sharp child, that girl looks sharp in her dress,to sharpen one's political
skills, a cutting-edge technology, a cutting reply, keen eyes, keen reasoning/insight,
the sting of ambition, a stinging comment, poignant interest, poignant scene,
a piquant wit, a piercing mind/question, an acute observer, a penetrating analysis,
a biting allegory/remark, mordant (from French 'mordant' biting) eyes, a thorny
issue, to be stunned by somebody's performance, his behavior came as shock,
their son's failure was a big blow, it was definitely a slap in the face, to
hit home, a catchy title/phrase, to pique (Fr.to inject) somebody's curiosity,
a television hit.
The antonyms to the expressions above connote slowness or lack of the mind's
brightness :
a blunt and tactless question,
II. Visual Metaphors
Visualization which is part of concretization consists of giving shape, form,
color, size and or light to abstract concepts. This metaphor which is universal
is used in everyday language unconsciouly by native speakers.
1. Form
Form metaphors give a physical form to concepts.
to paint the picture, to imagine, to give a whole picture, to be in the picture,
to come into the picture, there is more to the picture, to shape the rules of
the game, to miss from the picture, to give a clear picture, to put an X face
on something, to frame a question/debate , to cross the dots, to put on the
map, to be on the radar screen, to face problems.
Expressions which talk of the disappearance of the human body belong to this
type of metaphor as well.
to lack out of the picture, to evaporate, to melt away, to disappear into thin
air, to fall off the map of the world, some theories emerge and evaporate..
2. Shape
The shape metaphor gives a physical or moral personality to the object. Good
shape corresponds to what is considered good and bad shape to what is bad.
dirty tricks/ business, down-and-dirty expletives, an ugly fight, a messy divorce,
to clean up the mess, trash talking, a trashy tone, the administration is not
clean as far as the affair is concerned, to be filthy rich, to clear swomebody
of crimes, a crooked individual, a tattered economy, a sinuous insinuation,
a tortuous questioning, to bend the rules, a loose girl, to tarnish/to taint
somebody's reputation, the relationship between the two countries was disfigured
by the war, a beautiful feeling, a beautifully smoked fish, a well-rounded education,
a straight answer/individual, political adroitness, to be right, the right thing
to do, a circular argument, an oblique answer, an elegant prose, a beer with
an elegant smoothness, an inelegant stumbling, an attractive theory, a clean
election, a polished speech, to twist the truth, some pieces of the puzzle don't
quite fit in, to win fair and square elections, to set the record straight,
a direct person, to respond directly to the accusations, to taint somebody's
image, to paint a wrong picture, a neat report,the book neatly captures the
underlying nature of the subject, the claim doesn't square with the reality,
the relationship between the two countries was disfigured by the war .
3. Size :
The size linguistic expressions like the weight expressions are used to show
importance or impact. Large size suggests big importance and small size little
importance or impact.
a fat checking account, fat chance, a thich accent, a slim/thin victory, a
tiny chance, the literature on the subject is thin, the article was thin on
examples, to have a thin campaign theme, big money/business/moment, it's no
big deal, a monumental error, a mammoth task, a huge expense/impact, a colossal
failure, an outsized claim/drama, to build an oversized public profile, a sizable
cash donation , a widely shared view ,to widen an inquiry, a massive knowledge,
to make enormous strides, an enormous pressure, the plan was narrowly voted
down, a narrow academic discipline, in the big scheme of things, to think big,
to be in big trouble, a make a big fuss, an economical behemoth, a giant corporation,
a gigantic tax cut, a sea change, to have an immense influence, the spending
has zoomed, to be a mere drop in the ocean, a drop in the bucket, to play a
large role, a broad agenda, out of thin air, to be narrow-minded, a narrow /wide
range of issuest, to be dwarfed by, the shrinking of paychecks, to stretch the
imagination/truth/meaning, to stretch thin, a tiny circulation, to broaden the
scope of the mission, a microscopic experience, to become the 800-pound gorilla,
she will continue to loom large in American politics, to be larger than life,
a small effect, a little influence, to hold a tenuous position, a vast experience,
to inflate one's ego, meager means, a slender income, lean years, a miniscule
contribution, a deep thinker, a profound impact, a shallow character, a ballooning
federal deficit, through thich and thin, to be short of cash, new ideas are
in short supply, a long shot, a long memory, to have a long view, to take long
to do something, to be long on brains, a lengthy (verbose) speech, tall tales,
a tall order, a towering task, to expand an inquiry, he came out diminished
after the debate, a grandiose plan, the problem is humongous, to take baby steps.
4. Color :
The colors that are used as metaphors are mostly black and white. Black is
associated with what is not 'clean' such as illegal activities and 'white' symbolizes
wha t is acceptable.
to blackmail, to blacklist, black market, to have a black mark, black words,
a black lie,to have a black heart, black deeds, to see things in black and white,
to whitewash, white lie, white magic, white list, white alert, green party,
to paint a rosy picture.
Something which is not categorizable belongs to the gray area.
Color itseft is used as a metaphor to refer to additional features.
to have a colorful life,a colorful language, to color facts,a colorful individual,
a colorless politician, the author empurpled his prose.
5. Light
Light in all languages is the symbol of knowledge, wisdom , understanding and
well being. Intelligent people are those who have good eyes, look attentively
and can see far.
to be farsighted, a visionary leader, the book has opened her eyes on new things
that she never saw before, when will the country wake up, a wake-up call, to
be clear eyed, to be an eye opener, a clairvoyant leader, do you see what I
mean?, to open somebody's eyes, to dawn on X, clear-eyed thinking, lucid moments/explanation.
Ignorance is caused by having vision problems.
to be blinded, to be myopic, to lose sight, to be/keep in the dark, to be shortsighted,
I don't see your point, the solution was nowhere in sight.
Things to be known have to have visibility
to lift the veil, to shed light, to surface, to come to the surface, to bubble
up to the surface, to emerge, to highlight, to unearth the truth, to unmask
somebody's past , to discover, to uncover, to illuminate the past, to show,
to indicate, to demonstrate, to illuminate the underlying mechanism of a system,
to discover, to uncover , to give a glimse, to come into sharp focus, to be
in limeligt/spotlight, to lift somebody from obscurity, to clear the fog, to
be/put on display, to come into prominence, a prominent role, a spectacular
accomplishment, to come into the open, to come to light, somebody with high
visibility, to bring to light, to X in the open, to bring the issue out into
the open, to focus the lens on a subject, a panoramic view of African literature,
to push an issue into the spotlight, to be an eye opener, the social problems
caught the president's eye, to get the broadest possible scope of interest we
will know the facts when the dust settles, to give a clear explanation, a pellucid
explanation, a limpid style, to find an answer/solution, to rise from obscurity
to the highest position in the land, to lay the facts on the table, to put X
at the forefront, flash points, to lay the cards on the top of the table
Phenomena which are outside the visual scope cannot be known or understood.
to be kept in dark,to remain a dark mystery, to be shrouded in secrecy, to
be overshadowed, to drop out of race/sight, to cover up, to hide, to put a lid
on, to never see the light of the day, there are valuable things in life which
never see the light of the day for ages and ages, to be out of the picture,
to fade from view, to cloud the picture/ the mind, to be under a cloud of suspicion,
to mask a problem, the atmosphere will darken with the war in Irak, to obscure
the truth, to close one's eyes, to turn a blind eye, to look the other way,
to put behind X, to be blind to reality, the issues were buried in the background,
his popularity faded away, it is an open secret, to fade into oblivion, the
underlying meaning that lies in the deep, not to have the foggiest/faintest
idea , to cover up a crime, to cloud X's judgment, the fog of war, to escape
notice, to overlook the facts, to drop out of sight, to X behind closed doors,
a shadowy militant organization, to pale in comparison, to blur the lines/boundaries/borders,
the facts are still murky, not to have the foggiest/faintest idea, faint resemblance/idea,
to be eclipsed, there are more to X that meets the eye, an underground movement/organization,
the Undergrond Railroad, the underworld mafia, a murky radical movement, a dense
fog of political intrigue, a blind faith, to sweep under the rug, a closely
guarded secret, to X under the table, to be fired under the crowd of suspicion,
the details were kept under wraps.
The light is also a symbol of hope, healthy situation and lack of light the
opposite.
a bright future, bright and dark spots, a radiant personality, a ray/glimmer
of hope, a shining moment , a shining family, a stellar career, high society
luminaries, a galaxy of entertainers, to see the light at the end of the tunnel
, a sunny optimism, a sunny career, to bask in the glow of success, to beam
with happiness, to glow with pride, a transparent government, to have a gloomy
view of the situation, to glow with pride, a glowing comment, to dim hopes,
the polls added to the government's gloom, a somber ceremony, to issue a somber
warning, the visit bureau's lack of a good manager is the latest cloud to shadow
the tourism industry, to speak glowingly of somebody, not all was sunshine,
to gather glowing reviews.
To refuse to look or be prevented from looking is also cause of lack of knowledge
to look the other way, to turn one's back to reality, to turn a blind eye,
to cast a cloud over something, to keep in the dark.
Light is the embodiment of knowledge and darkness the personification of ignorance.
a luminous concept/report, a brilliant idea, a splendid idea, a sunny story,
a gleaming example, the Enlightenment Movement, a bright/brilliant child, academic
rising stars, an obscure writer/article, an opaque meaning, dark ages/past,
a murky situation/concept, a dim idea, a nebulous recollection, fuzzy thinking,
a hazy idea, a hidden agenda, a shadowy past, a twilight zone.
To see is to think
let me see what I can do, she is contemplating to change her career, she set
her sights on a political career, they are envisioning to move to Europe, to
see to it, to look into.
IV. Taste Metaphors :
Good taste metaphors are used to refer to any kind of pleasure whether it be
sensual, intellectual or spiritual. Unpleasant experiences are conceived as
bitter foods or drinks.. For instance, a victory is always sweet but a defeat
is bitter.
a voluptuous beauty/feel, saucy tales, juicy conversation, to juice up a story,
the senators peppered the secretary with questions about the killings of soldiers
in Iraq, meaty article, delicious book, her satirical abilities remain deliciously
undimmed, a bitter argument, to taste the bitter bread of defeat, raw politician,
a sour marriage/ relationship, a souring public mood, to relish one's new status,
a salty singer, a sweet victory, a succulent story, an acid remark, the theory
lost flavor, a hot and spicy novel, to spice up a story, the book contains juicy
vignettes, the news was juiced up for political purposes, to savor the sweet
ordinariness of daily life/victory, the play was pleasingly sweet and annoyingly
saccharine, an insipid tale, a vapid conversation, disgusting discussion, the
economy has soured, to have appetite for, to be hungry /thirsty for, a bittersweet
victory, the relationship between the two countries has soured, a sour economy,
his comments left a sour taste in her mouth, a delectable story, the bitterness
spills into the footnotes of the article, to relish adventure, the book is peppered
with anachronisms, to fight until the bitter end, to be embittered by a remark,
a bittersweet romantic comedy, a healthy appetite for minimalist art, a distaste
for any kind of ideology, the audience was salted with actors, the play was
spiced with lighter topical jokes, to add an international flavor, the performance
had the flavor of pop, the prime minister's statements were extraordinarily
tasteless, to have good tastes, a tastefully sleek office, a bad-taste comedy,
a seasoned politician, a raw answer, to sweeten a deal, a syrupy manner, bitter
pill to swallow, the killings of US soldiers in Iraq has sapped the Pentagon's
appetite for a new military undertaking, a voracious reader, palatable ideas,
unsavory truths/characters, a piquant smile, a tart comment, pungent wit/remark,
unappetizing remarks/comments.
V. Smelling Metaphors
Smelling metaphors are used to refer to things, events or situations that seem
suspicious.
the smell of corruption, to smell fishy, to smell a rat, to smell foul play,
everything smells, to scent trouble,
It is also interesting to notice that taste and smell metaphors are most of
the time mixed.
a spicy smell, a delicious smell, a sweet and delicious odor, sweet smell of
success,
VI. Hearing Metaphors
To hear , thus having good ears, entails understanding and interest whereas
problems in hearing or refusing to hear imply lack of interest or intellectual
capacity.
to be all ears, to be up to one's ears, to fall on deaf ears, to turn a deaf
ear, to go in one ear and out of the other, to enlist somebody as eyes and ears.
Clear, audible and resonant sounds correspond to satisfactory states or well-performed
events .
to make one's voice heard, to raise one's voice, flat answer,to strike a chord,
to strike a conciliatory note, a thounderous applause/ovation, to ring true,
to elevate to a fever pitch, to make a sales pitch, the performance was pitch
perfect, the argument was articulated with perfect pitch, a key-note speaker,to
be resonant with meaning, his reputation resonates far beyond his country, a
vociferous opposition, vibrant economy/future/colors/performance/personality,
a strident assertion, his actions have reverberated in all aspects of the society,
the complaints are growing loudest among the elite, a full-throated opposition,
to be resonant with visual symbols, to live in harmony, a harmonious relationship,
his reaction is consonant with his personality, to sound an upbeat note,to add
new vibrancy/harmony, pitch perfect, the orchestra gave a lighter than a thunderous
reading, everybody echoed the same view/sentiment, a roaring business, the results
are all over but shouting, to utter a libel, to have a pronounced position,
an articulate theory,to fine-tune a draft proposal, to be music to the ears,
buzz words.
Unpleasant sounds are associated with unpleasant phenomena.
there is a cacophony in the classroom, a cacophonic mixture of colors, a loud
denial, loud colors, a raucous portrayal, the car is screamingly red, she is
wearing a red dress that screams, roaring drunk, to ring hollow, a dissonant
court ruling, her dress is dissonant from her shoes, a discordant opinion, a
harsh treatment, his new assertions were toned down from his latest statements,
to mumble on a sandwish.
Conclusion
Metaphors exist because of the incapacity of the human brain to store all words
which refer to the infinite world. Since the brain is part of the human body
and the body experiences are the ones the brain experiences first and keeps
experienting all the time , it is logical that the body takes center stage among
the providers of conceptual metaphors. These body conceptual metaphors are found
in all languages, although some senses may be used more predominently in some
cultures than others because of environmental and social factors as expected
and predicted by different academic disciplines and theories.
|